Which Hogwarts House Would Sherlock Holmes Be in?

The enigmatic detective, Sherlock Holmes, created by the renowned writer Arthur Conan Doyle, would likely be sorted into the house of Ravenclaw at Hogwarts. This house values intelligence, wisdom, and a thirst for knowledge, all of which align closely with Holmes' exceptional deductive reasoning and analytical skills.

Howard's keen intellect, logical approach to problem-solving, and deep curiosity about the world around him are highly regarded in Ravenclaw. His primary qualities—intelligence, logic, and curiosity—resonate more with the ideals of Ravenclaw than they do with other houses. While one might also consider elements of Slytherin due to his cunning and resourcefulness, his primary qualities align more closely with the ideals of Ravenclaw.

Ravenclaw

Ravenclaw House qualities: Intelligence, Wisdom, Thirst for Knowledge

During the sorting ceremony at Hogwarts, Gryffindor is often pitted against Ravenclaw. However, both these houses would most likely be in Ravenclaw, where knowledge is prioritized above all else. This implies that the sorting hat would prioritize intellectual ability and wisdom over other qualities such as bravery or leadership.

Gryffindor

Gryffindor House qualities: Daring, Nerve, Chivalry, and Fierce Loyalty

Statements in support of Holmes' suitability for Gryffindor:

Daring: Holmes is prepared to take huge risks to accomplish his missions. He performed burglary and acted recklessly to secure his client’s victory. Nerve: He never loses his nerve even in cases where the evidence against his client is very strong. He always puts faith in himself and ensures his client’s success. Chivalry: Holmes is among the most chivalrous characters of Victorian literature. He fought and defeated the mighty Prof. Moriarty and Baron Adelbert Gruner, despite being severely beaten by the latter. This mission was akin to stealing prey from a lion's den. Fierce Loyalty: Holmes is fiercely loyal to those close to him, such as Dr. Watson. He is willing to go to extreme lengths, including acts of violence, to protect his friends and relatives.

Considering these qualities and his deducing powers, it is evident why Holmes would be a fitting member of the House of Godric Gryffindor. He would align well with other Gryffindors like Minerva McGonagall, Albus Dumbledore, and Hermione Granger, whom the Sorting Hat seriously considered putting in Ravenclaw.

Why Sherlock Holmes Isn't in Ravenclaw

Holmes is not in Ravenclaw because the qualities of Ravenclaw require extensive bookish knowledge and reasoning power. While Holmes has exceptional reasoning ability, he lacks knowledge on fundamental facts, such as the earth revolving around the sun. A person who doesn't know such basic information cannot be a member of the Ravenclaw house.

Why Sherlock Holmes Isn't in Slytherin

Holmes is not in Slytherin because he is not ambitious. He frequently leaves the credit for many of his cases, showcasing a lack of malicious cunning. However, he is determined to defeat notorious criminals of his generation. His determination and bravery, characteristic of Gryffindor, are more fitting than the ambition or cunning characteristic of Slytherin.

Thank you for reading this article. If you found it interesting, we would appreciate your upvote!