Which Harry Potter Character is the Most Overrated and Underrated

When it comes to the Harry Potter series, fans often agree that certain characters stand out as either overly praised or overlooked. In this article, we will delve into the reasons behind which characters might be overrated and underrated. By analyzing the development of these characters throughout the series, we will provide insights into why they have become so significant or, in some cases, why they might deserve more recognition.

Overrated

The Marauders and Their Circle

The Marauders and all their friends, enemies, and kin – no topic in the Harry Potter fandom is as hotly debated as the Marauders (James, Sirius, Remus, and Peter) and their circle of friends. Fans speculate endlessly about their lives, adventures, and even their adversaries. While they undoubtedly add depth and excitement to the series, they are often seen as more prominent than they should be.

James Potter is a prime example of a character who is not as well-developed as one might think. While his flaws are laid bare for all to see, his strengths are often mentioned only secondhand, making them less impactful. Lily Evans, on the other hand, is portrayed as the perfect dream girl despite lacking any significant depth. Her kindness and bravery seem merely theoretical, and her irritable nature makes her less relatable than intended.

Sirius Black and Remus Lupin are often seen as the most exciting characters, but their emotional and developmental journeys are often lacking. Sirius is seen as fun and wild, but his "principles" may lean more towards contrarianism rather than genuine moral convictions. Remus, while a bit better developed, still draws more on outside sources like Pottermore for his inner life. Regulus Black's story is a favorite for many, but his significance lies solely in his death, leaving him underdeveloped and underappreciated.

Snape: A Character That Deserves More Appreciation

Snape is a character who is often seen as overrated and underrated simultaneously. He is undoubtedly an excellent character, but his role as a spy is often seen as the most significant aspect of his character. However, Snape's development throughout the series seems to be underexplored. His worldview doesn't appear to change significantly, and his actions are often driven by personal motivations rather than a deeper moral compass. The fact that he turns against Voldemort out of fear for Lily and protects Harry out of guilt over her death does not necessarily indicate a profound change in his character. It is questionable whether his moral opposition to the Dark Arts extends beyond these specific instances.

Underrated

Harry and Ron: The Often Overlooked Heroes

Harry and Ron are frequently criticized for their flaws and perceived shortcomings. However, both characters are far more complex and admirable than they are often given credit for. Harry's anger is often highlighted, but his capacity for forgiveness and his refusal to kick someone when they're down is frequently overlooked. While Hermione is praised for these qualities, Harry also demonstrates them. Ron's unwavering support and generosity towards Harry during his darkest moments are often underestimated. While he may be seen as a bit of a slacker, his character is far more developed and admirable than is usually acknowledged.

Both Harry and Ron undergo significant growth throughout the series, but they are often portrayed as lone wolves or single-minded individuals. Their relationship is tested multiple times, but it ultimately endures. Ron is not a fair-weather friend; he's a loyal and steadfast companion who sticks by Harry's side through thick and thin. Despite their sometimes rocky relationship, they rely on each other and grow together, making them far more than just protagonists in a series.

Narcissa Malfoy and Andromeda Tonklin are two characters who are often overlooked. Narcissa is a complex figure who would go to great lengths for her family. However, her loyalty to her beliefs and family also means that she never fully rejects Voldemort's philosophy. Similarly, Andromeda's strong personality and complex background make her one of the most intriguing characters, yet she is often underappreciated.

So, which Harry Potter character is the most overrated or underrated? The Marauders and their circle, Snape, and even characters like Narcissa Malfoy and Andromeda Tonklin can be seen as underappreciated. Harry and Ron, on the other hand, often go overlooked but are far more complex and admirable than their flaws suggest.