Which Ghostbusters Film Is Superior? A Comparative Analysis

The debate between Ghostbusters 1986 and Ghostbusters 2 has been ongoing among fans for decades, with many advocating for the original film as the superior work. This analysis will explore the reasons behind the preference for the original Ghostbusters, examining its superior craftsmanship, lasting appeal, and the unsatisfactory impact of Ghostbusters 2.

Ghostbusters 1986: A Superior Craftsmanship

Released in 1984 before the actual 1986 Ghostbusters film, the 1986 version is often considered a much better movie. Composer Bernard Herrmann, known for his work on Jaws and Gone with the Wind, directed this film, bringing a unique level of quality and sophistication to the project. Herrmann's film score is particularly noteworthy, as it captures the essence of late 1970s and early 1980s horror films more effectively than that of Ghostbusters 2.

The narrative and character development in Ghostbusters 1986 are also hallmarks of superior filmmaking. The film delves into the backstory of the protagonists, explaining how they formed the Ghostbusters and justified their actions. This level of detail contributes to a richer, more engaging story. Furthermore, the chemistry between the main characters is palpable, making the film's humor and thrills more authentic and effective.

Why Ghostbusters 2 Failed to Live Up to the Original

Contrary to popular belief, Ghostbusters 2 was not a straightforward sequel. Instead, it was conceived as a cash-grab by Columbia Pictures, made in the wake of the original film's success. The decision to proceed with a sequel without the involvement of co-creator Dan Aykroyd and the ensemble cast who performed so well in the original is a significant factor in the film's lackluster reception.

Aykroyd, known for his sharp wit and charisma, is notably absent from Ghostbusters 2. This absence is keenly felt, given his central role in bringing the original film to life. The film also fails to capture the lighter, more whimsical tone of the first movie, instead opting for a heavier, more dramatic storyline. This shift felt forced and unconvincing, leading to a film that feels like a shadow of its predecessor rather than an extension of it.

Impact of Ghostbusters 2 on the Series

Interestingly, Ghostbusters 2 did pave the way for the 2016 Ghostbusters reboot. While not a direct predecessor, the 2016 film addressed some of the shortcomings of Ghostbusters 2 by bringing back core elements from the original, such as the talented cast and the light-hearted, ensemble-driven storytelling. However, the 2016 film too faced its own set of challenges, with many critics and fans citing it as a departure from the spirit of the original.

Despite the 2016 film's attempt to pay homage to the past, the influence of Ghostbusters 2 can still be discerned. It laid the groundwork for larger narratives, more expansive sets, and bigger special effects—a direction that the 2016 film took further. Nonetheless, the original 1986 film remains the foundation and the heart of the franchise, its strengths a stark contrast to the shortcomings of both Ghostbusters 2 and the 2016 remake.

Conclusion

The original Ghostbusters and, more specifically, the 1986 version, stand out as superior for their craftsmanship, character development, and overall entertainment value. While Ghostbusters 2 had its good moments, it ultimately falls short of the original in terms of quality and execution. For fans who value the spirit of the franchise and enjoy a more thoughtful, engaging horror-comedy, the original Ghostbusters remains the gold standard.