Which Film Do You Prefer: IT 2017 or IT: Chapter Two 2019?

About the Films

It is often said that the best kind of horror film is one that tackles the psychological and philosophical aspects of evil and fear. In that regard, IT 2017 and IT: Chapter Two 2019 are both masterpieces that explore these elements in their unique ways. Both films, however, present entirely different takes on the story, making it difficult to determine which one is superior.

The sheep in the barn represents the audience's viewing experience of the films. For the film set in 1990, the 2017 version, the sheep finds its place at the center of the herd, symbolizing the film's central role in the world of horror cinema. It injects new life into the classic theme of a clown embodying evil, and it uses these modern elements to initiate a fresh debate about fear and supernatural evil.

Personal Preferences

On a personal note, I found IT 2017 to be the more enjoyable film. Personally, I felt that Chapter Two lacked in its plot development and, in the end, the storyline was not as engaging as in the first film. The 2017 version delves deeper into the narrative, and its plot is more intricate and thrilling.

Why IT 2017 Was Better in My Opinion

IT 2017 struck me as the superior film for a variety of reasons. One of the primary reasons is the perfect casting of the young actors. Every character felt well-acted and engaging, contributing to the film's overall suspense and scare factor. Additionally, the modern setting of the film, placing the Losers' Club at 13-14 years old, felt more relatable for a contemporary audience. The rewatchability of this film is also a significant advantage.

While the first film had its emphasis on speed effects and less speaking time for Pennywise's actor, it still left a lasting impact on the audience. The suspense and jump scare scenes were executed exceptionally well, posing a significant emotional threat to the viewers.

Why IT: Chapter Two 2019 Was Enjoyable Too, Though Differently

That being said, IT: Chapter Two 2019 has its own merits. The film takes place in a more modern era, making it easier for audiences to connect with the characters. The emotional impact of the story was more profound in this adaptation, which gave the viewers a deeper dive into the characters of each of the original cast members. The additional scenes with the younger cast members provided a fresh perspective on the protagonists' backstories.

Our Final Thoughts

In conclusion, while both films are outstanding, I would argue that IT 2017 stands out slightly above the other. The perfect casting and the ability to rewatch and enjoy it multiple times make it a standout choice. However, those who prefer a more modern take on the story might prefer IT: Chapter Two 2019.

Ultimately, whichever film you prefer, both IT and IT: Chapter Two are monumental achievements in the world of horror. They are essential viewing for fans of the genre and for those interested in the psychological and philosophical aspects of fear and evil.