Which Famous Comedian Should You Stranded with on a Deserted Island for a Year?

The question of which famous comedian to be stranded with on a deserted island for a year has sparked many debates. The right answer should take into consideration not just their humor, but also their approach to life and character.

Bob Newhart: The Quiet Groove

When it comes to choosing a comedian, one answer stands out: Bob Newhart. Known for his low-key, deadpan, and self-effacing nature, Newhart has a unique charm that would make staying on a deserted island for a year feel like a breeze compared to other comedians who could drive you crazy in a short time.

Gilligan's Choice: Bob Denver

However, there is a notable mention of Bob Denver as Gilligan in Gilligan's Island. He brings a level of experience and relatability that would be comforting in such a situation. Although the choice is straightforward, we should also consider Ginger Grant's character from the movie, which adds an intriguing twist.

Sarah Silverman: The Intelligent and Captivating Choice

Sarah Silverman is another compelling choice because of her intelligence, humor, and good looks. Her faith might be a potential barrier, but the idea of building a small temple in her honor or even a palace on an island is charmingly romantic. However, she might be a challenging choice for practical survival tasks like building shelters.

Norm MacDonald: The Perfect Blend

Norm MacDonald is a clear front-runner. He is funny, intelligent, and handsome. He might not excel at building shelters or hunting for supplies, but his overall charm makes him an ideal companion for the deserted island scenario. The idea of being stranded with someone so intelligent and witty is a great way to pass the time.

George Carlin's Intellectual Stimulus

George Carlin is another excellent choice. While he may not be known as a character comedian, his sharp wit and ability to provoke thought make him a great intellectual companion. However, the contradiction lies in his tendency to keep us on our toes with his sharp comments.

Robin Williams: The Circle of Characters

Robin Williams is a name that springs to mind when we think of versatility and character playing. He could keep us entertained with his breadth of characters and improvisational skills for the full year. Pair him with Jonathan Winters, and the island might feel more like a stage than a remote location.

Richard Pryor: The Epiphany and Inspiration

For Richard Pryor, the memories of young laughter shared during albums could be a strong bond, but his characters weren't as prominent as his peers. However, the unique connection he brought to comedy is undeniable. His presence would provide a mix of humor and life lessons, making the journey more memorable.

Ultimately, the choice of a comedian to keep you company on a deserted island comes down to what qualities you value most—be it intelligence, humor, or character depth. Whether you choose Bob Newhart, Sarah Silverman, or Robin Williams, ensure you pick the person who will keep your spirits high and provide a little bit of entertainment during those long months on the deserted island.