What if Beric had not been Sent after the Mountain? Would He Have Joined Renly's Army?

Introduction

The concept of Beric Dondarrion, the leader of the Brotherhood Without Banners (Brotherhood), receiving a secret mission to kill The Mountain (Tywin Lannister) before joining Renly Baratheon's army is an intriguing one. However, the reality of Beric’s loyalty is complex, as explored herein. This article delves into the hypothetical scenario where Beric did not receive this mission from Stannis and investigates whether he might have joined Renly's army.

The Complex Loyalties of Beric Dondarrion

Beric Dondarrion's loyalties are an enigma. At one point in A Song of Ice and Fire, he addresses Stannis Baratheon as 'Lord Stannis,' which is unexpected given that he supports Stannis on two counts: as his liege lord and as the only ruler proclaiming devotion to the Many-Faced God (R'hollor).

This inconsistency suggests that Beric's loyalty is not straightforward. His allegiance to the Brotherhood Without Banners further complicates the issue. The Brotherhood is known for its political agenda, yet they vehemently deny having one. They claim to be followers of the Red God but reveal a more complex, multigod religion.

Hypothetical Scenario: Beric as a Possible F SEGon Supporter

The question arises as to whether Beric might have been a supporter of F SEGon. F SEGon was Stannis' brother, and his support would have significant implications on Beric's actions.

If Beric were a supporter of F SEGon, he might follow the path of House Redwyne, who are also likely F SEGon supporters. House Redwyne maintained neutrality during the civil war, thereby not joining either Renly or Stannis. Their neutrality deprived Renly's forces of a crucial ally like the Dondarrions, who, as noted, fielded a host of 4,000 men.

Scenario: Beric Staying Neutral in King's Landing

Had Beric chosen to remain neutral in King's Landing, he and his forces would not have declared for Renly. Instead, they might have continued their strategic stance, splitting loyalties similar to House Swann. This internal conflict would not have threatened Renly's forces.

Information obtained by the Brotherhood would have been crucial to Renly, but Beric's lack of support would have been a significant blow. Consequently, Beric's absence could have swayed the balance of forces in the south, potentially altering the outcome of events leading to the Battle of the Blackwater.

Alternative Scenario: Beric Declares for Renly

Alternatively, if Beric had no political agenda and simply followed the opportunity presented by Renly, he would most likely have joined Renly's army before the coup. In this scenario, he could have been at the Battle of the Blackwater and, upon Renly's death, either died alongside the forces of the Brotherhood or fled to join Stannis.

Consequences of Beric's Involvement

The lack of the Brotherhood Without Banners would significantly alter the course of the conflict. Arya Stark and Gendry, losing their ally, would wander the Riverlands, potentially encountering pro-Stark or pro-Lannister forces. This would complicate their journey to Braavos, and without the Brotherhood, Arya's fate would be uncertain.

If Arya were captured, the Night's King (NK) would target Bran Stark, Winterfell, and possibly both Daenerys Targaryen and Jon Snow. The NK's subsequent conquests would lead to the death of most major characters, including Arya if she made it back to Westeros.

Conclusion

The absence of Beric Dondarrion from Renly's army would have had far-reaching effects, leading to a different outcome in several critical battles. The complex nature of Beric's allegiances makes his potential actions in this alternate scenario even more intriguing. The hypothetical scenario not only explores Beric's role but also sheds light on the political landscape of A Song of Ice and Fire.

Key Takeaways:

Beric Dondarrion's loyalties are complex and not easily defined. His potential as a F SEGon supporter or remaining neutral would have altered the conflict dynamics. The absence of the Brotherhood Without Banners would have significantly impacted key events in Season 1.

By understanding Beric's role, we can better grasp the intricate web of alliances and politics in Westeros, making the series even more engaging.