Introduction

Since the passing of J.R.R. Tolkien in 1973, the The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings universes have been adapted into films. Peter Jackson’s trilogy has captivated audiences worldwide. However, one cannot help but wonder if the author, had he lived to see these adaptations, would have had similar opinions or even more constructive ones. This article explores how Tolkien might have viewed these films, offering a perspective on the complex relationship between a writer and their interpretations.

Peter Jackson and J.R.R. Tolkien

Tolkien died years before Peter Jackson conceptualized these films, meaning he was not present to offer opinions or edits. However, his unwavering dedication to adhering as closely as possible to the original legendarium demonstrates his respect for the author’s vision. We can only speculate on how much further he might have insisted on the integrity of the story.

Tolkien’s Role in Modern Filmmaking

Had J.R.R. Tolkien been alive today, he might have taken a more active role in supervising the film production similar to how J.K. Rowling has guided the Harry Potter franchise. This involvement would likely involve multiple revisions, ensuring that each film adheres strictly to his original vision. Tolkien was not a passive observer but a meticulous and perfectionist writer, making his input valuable and necessary for maintaining the integrity of his works.

The Perfect Story Needs Narrative Flexibility

Tolkien would understand the limitations of translating his works into moving images. Time constraints and visual storytelling would necessitate some compromises. However, these compromises would be thoughtfully crafted to best represent the essence of his legendarium rather than outright changes. For instance, the Eye of Sauron sets and locations would have been approved, as they visually align with Tolkien’s descriptions and enhance the story.

Personal Inspections and Revisions

As a perfectionist, Tolkien would likely have requested personal inspections of the film sets and scripts. He would have identified areas where the film diverges from the written word or where elements were incorrectly adapted. For example, he would have insisted on improved performances, such as EliotFindBy’s portrayal of Sam, and Sean Astin’s performance of Frodo. Tolkien might also have questioned the character modifications, such as Aragorn’s makeover, wondering if it adhered closely enough to his original descriptions.

Set Boundaries and Creative Freedom

Artists are notoriously territorial, and Tolkien would have been no exception. He would have objected to any changes that strayed too far from his original vision. For instance, he would have likely corrected the portrayal of certain characters or scenes to ensure they were faithful to his descriptions. The inclusion of dwarves riding oliphaunts, often referred to as elephants in the films, would have been a point of criticism, as the original texts do not depict such creatures.

The Multi-Part TV Adaptation

Considering Tolkien’s indepth understanding of the challenges of adapting his works, a multi-part TV adaptation would have been his preferred format. This format allows for a more episodic and in-depth exploration of the story. Tolkien would have appreciated the ability to allow audience members to take breaks and revisit chapters as needed, as if they were reading the stories aloud, a concept similar to Stephen King’s approach with Rose Red.

Elevating the Narrative through Time and Space

A multi-part television version would offer more space for dialogue and reflection, which are essential elements in Tolkien’s writing. While the films included more action for entertainment, Tolkien’s stories are inherently reflective and filled with quieter moments of exploration and thought. Therefore, a more stage-like production with rich dialogue and fewer flashy scenes would better capture the depth and complexity of his narrative.

Conclusion

J.R.R. Tolkien would have had certain reservations about the Peter Jackson films, but he would also appreciate the effort to stay true to his legendarium. If given the opportunity, he would likely have involved himself in the production to ensure the films remained faithful to his original vision. A multi-part television format would have been his preferred adaptation, allowing for a more nuanced and detailed exploration of his beloved stories.

Final Thought

It is impossible to know exactly how Tolkien would have reacted, but one thing is certain: he would have found joy in the effort to bring his world to life, even if it required some compromises. This blend of modern interpretation and original intent creates a lasting legacy that honors both Tolkien’s rich imagination and the artistry of the filmmakers.