Introduction

As fans of The Sopranos remember, the series came to a close with a definitive and somewhat bittersweet ending. An intriguing what-if scenario arises when we ponder what might have happened if a pivotal moment in the final episode led to a different outcome. This article explores the fascinating question of what would have happened to Tony Soprano if the Members Only Guy (MOG) had missed him and killed Meadow instead. This scenario shifts the course of events in ways that could have sent Tony down a drastically different path, affecting not only his career but also his personal life.

Seizing the Moment: The MOG's Action and Its Impact

The pivotal moment in the final scene of the series is the shot where Tony is shot by MOG as he exits the bathroom. This critical event occurs just before 5 o'clock, where MOG, walking past Tony's table, observes Tony and then enters the bathroom. The scene is underscored by a tracking shot that follows MOG's movements into and out of the bathroom, emphasizing the gravity of the situation and MOG's choice.

The camera does not literally pan and move within the bathroom but rather fluidly moves the exterior scene, further oblivious to Tony, allowing MOG to get a clear shot at him. The bathroom acts as an eerie conduit for both MOG and Tony, as it positions Tony in a vulnerable position, leaving him defenseless. It's a masterstroke of television drama, designed to convey a sense of inevitability and foreboding.

Alternative Ending and Its Consequences

Fortunately for the integrity of the show, the writers chose not to alter this key moment. However, what if MOG had missed Tony and instead killed Meadow, Tony's daughter? The Members Only Guy's action could have had catastrophic consequences, not only for Tony personally but also for the dynamic within his crew and family.

Personal Devastation and Family Breakdown

The loss of Meadow would be a profoundly devastating blow for Tony, reminiscent of the chilling ending of The Godfather III. Such an event would likely be a breaking point for his marriage with Carmela. Tony’s resilience and ability to carry on the life of a mob boss would be further tested, potentially leading to a crisis of faith and a turning point in his life. The psychological and emotional toll would be immense, and the subsequent fallout on his family relationships would be undeniable.

Strained Relationships and Business Complications

Beyond personal anguish, the murder of Meadow could have serious ramifications for the businesses Tony operates. Given that the titled figure MOG could be an ordinary customer or have no tangible connection to the criminal underworld, his motives and identity would remain ambiguous. This ambiguity adds to the complexity of the situation, leaving Tony in a state of confusion as to who to trust and how to proceed.

Exploring the New Path: Tony's Choices and Future

One speculative scenario could be that Tony, in a moment of sheer desperation, might consider ratting on his own network or even the city of New York. The revelation of this shocking act would likely be fueled by a sense of vengeance and despair. In his mind, the death of his daughter might prompt him to expose the injustices he has seen, driven by a desire to make things right, no matter the cost or the consequences.

Surrendering Control to Little Carmine

Alternatively, Tony could take a path similar to Little Carmine and choose to step away from the criminal life. He might hand over his business to someone more capable and allow himself to live a quieter life. This decision would be a denouement for the Soprano saga, symbolizing Tony's acknowledgment that the life he has led is too perilous and too destructive to continue. The transition could be gradual, with Tony slowly withdrawing from active participation in criminal activities, dedicating his time and energy to his family and personal interests.

In conclusion, the hypothetical scenario of MOG missing Tony and instead killing Meadow presents a myriad of what-ifs and what-mights in The Sopranos narrative. These possibilities could have dramatically altered the series' resolution, adding depth and complexity to Tony's character and the overall story. Whether Tony's tragedy would lead to a betrayal, a personal transformation, or a quiet ascetic life, it leaves fans to wonder about the countless paths not taken in the ever-compelling world of The Sopranos.