What Would Have Happened if Robb Stark Had Marched Back North After Ned’s Death?

If Robb Stark had marched back North instead of leading his army to the south to avenge his father Ned Stark's death, the course of the War of the Five Kings and the broader conflict in Westeros could have been significantly altered. Here are several possible outcomes.

Strengthening the North

By returning to the North, Robb could have strengthened his power and consolidated his position in Winterfell. This would have allowed him to rally the Northern bannermen around a common cause, potentially uniting them more effectively against the Lannisters.

Avoiding Distraction

Robb's initial decision to march south led to a series of military engagements that stretched his resources thin. By retreating to the North, he could have focused on defending his home territory and preparing for future conflicts rather than engaging in battles that weakened his position.

Political Alliances

Remaining in the North might have allowed Robb to forge stronger alliances with other Northern houses, such as House Manderly or House Umber. This could have increased his military strength and resources, enabling him to launch a more coordinated campaign against the Lannisters later on.

Impact on the War of the Five Kings

Robb's absence from the southern conflicts could have led to a different power dynamic among the other claimants to the Iron Throne. The Lannisters and Stannis Baratheon might have faced less opposition, potentially allowing them to consolidate power more effectively.

The Fate of the Stark Family

If Robb had returned to the North, he might have been better able to protect his family and the Stark legacy. The absence of his southern campaigns could have changed the fate of his mother Catelyn and his sisters Sansa and Arya, who faced significant dangers during this time.

Long-term Consequences

A strong Northern presence could have led to a different outcome in the eventual conflicts with the White Walkers. If the North had been more united and prepared, they might have been better equipped to deal with the threat from beyond the Wall.

In summary, if Robb Stark had chosen to return to the North after Ned Stark's death, it could have led to a stronger Northern alliance, a more strategic approach to warfare, and potentially altered the fate of House Stark and the broader political landscape of Westeros.

What do you think? How do you think the outcome of the War of the Five Kings would have been different if Robb had marched back north after Ned's death?