What If the Policeman Had Investigated? The Impact of a Missed Opportunity in ‘The Godfather Part II’

In The Godfather Part II, the scene where Clemenza and Vito Corleone are stealing the rug is a pivotal moment that establishes Vito's character and the early dynamics of his criminal activities. This single act sets a foundation for his future rise to power in the organized crime world. However, what if the policeman had opened the door and investigated when he saw Clemenza and Vito stealing the rug? Let's explore the potential outcomes that could have unfolded.

Arrest and Consequences

If the policeman had discovered Clemenza and Vito in the act, they would likely have been arrested. This could have significantly altered Vito's trajectory, potentially preventing him from rising to power in the organized crime world. An arrest could have led to a criminal record, making it more difficult for him to gain respect and build alliances in the future.

Increased Scrutiny

The incident could have attracted further police attention to Vito's activities. A criminal record or even an arrest would have made it harder for him to operate in the shadows. Increased law enforcement scrutiny could have led to more frequent raids, making it more challenging for Vito and his associates to continue their illicit activities.

Impact on Vito's Family

An arrest could have had severe repercussions for Vito's family. His wife Carmela and their children would have faced social stigma, financial instability, and the potential for further legal issues. This might have influenced Vito's choices regarding his family's involvement in crime.

Change in Relationships

The failed burglary could have strained Vito's relationship with Clemenza and other associates. If they had been caught, there might have been blame and distrust among the crew, impacting their future collaborations and possibly splitting their group.

Shift in Power Dynamics

Vito's early criminal endeavors, including this incident, laid the groundwork for his later rise in the Mafia. If this early attempt had failed, it could have created a power vacuum that other crime families might have exploited. Different crime families might have gained the upper hand, leading to a different landscape of organized crime in New York.

Ultimately, if the policeman had intervened, it would likely have set off a chain reaction that altered Vito Corleone's path and the overall narrative of the Corleone family in the saga. This event could have served as a turning point in the story, highlighting the delicate balance between opportunity and consequence in the world of organized crime.