What If Stannis Baratheon Claimed the Iron Throne?

The events of A Song of Ice and Fire series, particularly the A Game of Thrones books, describe a world where power is fiercely fought over. One pivotal moment in this tale involves the contest for the Iron Throne between Stannis Baratheon and his brother Robert. A different outcome would have dramatically altered the narrative and political landscape of Westeros. This article explores some of the potential outcomes if Stannis had ascended to the throne.

Different Leadership Style

Stannis Baratheon, a forthright ruler with a staunch adherence to law and duty, has a markedly different leadership style compared to his brother Robert. Robert, known for his charisma and indulgent nature, often operates on a less structured basis. If Stannis had become king, his reign would have been heavily focused on justice and order, which could alienate supporters who prefer a more lenient and charismatic leader. This would have significant implications for the way the Seven Kingdoms were governed and the relationships between houses and the crown.

The Role of Melisandre

Stannis is deeply influenced by the red priestess Melisandre, who serves as a key advisor and supporter of his reign. Melisandre's belief in the Lord of Light would likely lead to a series of religiously motivated policies and conflicts, particularly with the predominant Faith of the Seven. This could create tensions within Westeros, as different values and beliefs clash.

Handling of Rivals

Stannis is known for his ruthless and calculating approach to his enemies. Unlike Robert, who was more lenient and sometimes enjoyed the pleasures of power, Stannis would likely pursue an aggressive campaign against rivals. His strategic use of force could lead to earlier and more intense conflicts, potentially sparking the War of the Five Kings well before its actual onset. This approach would make the political climate in Westeros more unstable and fraught with danger.

Support from the North

Stannis, being the older brother of Robert, might have enjoyed greater legitimacy in the eyes of the North, particularly if he had successfully allied with House Stark. The North, traditionally skeptical of the ironborn and the Lannisters, would likely have felt more allegiance to Stannis, especially if his claim was validated by his familial relationship to Robert. This support could significantly bolster his claim to the throne and provide a solid base for his rule.

Potential for War

The early rise of Stannis to the throne could spark significant wars as various factions challenge his authority more aggressively. The Lannisters, historically at odds with the Baratheons, would likely view Stannis as a threat and react with force. Other claimants to the throne, such as Renly Baratheon, would also perceive his rise as a challenge to their legitimacy. This could lead to an earlier and more widespread conflict, altering the course of events seen in the series.

Impact on Key Events

Several key events, such as the Battle of Blackwater, would have played out differently under Stannis's rule. His strategic decisions, tied to his rigid moral code, could lead to different outcomes and approaches. For instance, he might have employed more cautious and calculated strategies, potentially altering the results of skirmishes and battles. This could have significant consequences for the balance of power in the Seven Kingdoms.

The Iron Throne's Legacy

Stannis's reign, focused on legitimacy and justice, would likely result in a more stable and less corrupt government. However, his strict moral code and rigid adherence to duty might also lead to a more tyrannical form of governance, potentially leading to resistance and rebellion from those who oppose his methods. This could create a more tumultuous and conflict-ridden Westeros, in sharp contrast to Robert's more indulgent and carefree reign.

In conclusion, the ascension of Stannis Baratheon to the Iron Throne would have profound effects on the political and social landscape of Westeros. His unique brand of leadership, coupled with his close ties to Melisandre and the religious movements she represents, would create a complex and often challenging environment for the Seven Kingdoms.