What If Hela Had Won in Thor: Ragnarok? An Analysis of the Impact on the MCU

In the final moments of Thor: Ragnarok, Hela's defeat by Thor and Loki seems a foregone conclusion. However, what if Hela had won? The implications for the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) would be significant, reshaping the very fabric of Asgard and the Nine Realms.

Asgard's Destruction

With Hela successfully defeating both Thor and Loki, the Goddess of Death would likely consolidate her power over Asgard. Asgard, as a fortress of light and order, would see its end leading to its complete destruction. This would mark the final chapter for the Asgardian civilization as known in the MCU. The loss of this ancient realm would pave the way for a new and darker era in the universe.

Conquest of the Nine Realms

Having established control over Asgard, Hela might extend her dominion beyond the realms, imposing her rule over Jotunheim, Vanaheim, Nidavellir, and beyond. Her Godhood as the Goddess of Death would be a force to be reckoned with, potentially leading to widespread chaos and a power vacuum within the Nine Realms. This could result in conflicts with other factions or characters in the MCU, such as the Frost Giants, the Dark Elves, or even the mighty Thor himself.

Thor's Journey

Thor's character arc would take a darker turn. Instead of becoming a more mature and responsible leader, he might be driven by a desire for revenge or redemption. This complex and conflicted version of the character would make for a more nuanced narrative, delve deeper into his inner turmoil, and explore the consequences of his actions. Such a path would challenge the audience's understanding of Thor's heroic ideals and the true nature of leadership in a time of darkness.

Loki's Fate

Loki, with his complicated relationship with Hela, would have an uncertain future. He might choose to ally himself with her for survival, but this uneasy alliance could be short-lived. Alternatively, he could attempt to betray her for personal gain or to restore his own power. His fate would be a web of treachery, potential redemption, or further manipulation, adding layers to his already complex character.

Impact on the Avengers

Hela's victory could lead to a significant shift in the dynamics of the Avengers. With Thor unable to return to Earth, the team would be without one of its strongest members when facing future threats, such as Thanos. This would force the other Avengers to adapt and find new allies within the realms. This period of adjustment could lead to a more cohesive team, with each member taking on a greater role, but it would also present challenges as they navigate a new and increasingly dangerous universe.

Introduction of New Characters

Hela's rule might introduce new antagonists or allies as various beings within the MCU react to her rise to power. This could set the stage for new storylines involving characters like Doctor Strange, the Guardians of the Galaxy, or even Spider-Man, who might find himself on the front lines of the cosmic conflict. The emergence of these new characters would add depth to the story and expand the universe in exciting new directions.

Themes of Death, Power, and Tyranny

Hela's victory would likely emphasize themes of death, power, and tyranny, contrasting with the previous themes of heroism and unity in the MCU. This could lead to darker narratives and more complex moral dilemmas for the characters. The audience would be invited to question the nature of power and the true cost of victory in a world where the forces of darkness have taken control.

Conclusion

Overall, Hela's victory would result in a darker, more chaotic MCU, with significant changes to character development and future story arcs. This scenario would challenge the status quo and force the characters to confront the consequences of their actions in a universe where the balance of power is constantly shifting.