What If Benjen Stark Returned to the Wall Alive: Shifts in the Game of Thrones World
Welcome to the Possibilities
Introduction to the Scenario
The possibil
Welcome to the Possibilities
Introduction to the Scenario
The possibilities are endless when considering the outcome of events within the rich world of Game of Thrones. One such scenario involves the fate of Benjen Stark, who, if he were to return to the Wall alive, could significantly alter the course of the story. This article explores the potential ramifications and shifts that would unfold in the wake of Benjen's return, particularly focusing on his role as Lord Commander and his strategic importance in the battle against the White Walkers.Truly Back at the Wall
In a testament to his dedication and strategic acumen, Benjen Stark's return to the Wall could propel him to the esteemed position of Lord Commander. Upon his return, Stark's presence would solidify his legacy as a renowned leader, adding a new chapter to the noble history of the Night's Watch. However, it is equally plausible that fate may claim him at the Fist of the First Men, adding a touch of poignancy to his heroism.Brotherhood Beyond the Wall
Benjen's survival and return to the Wall would transform the dynamics on the other side of the Wall, notably for Bran Stark and Meera Reed. If Bran and Meera were to tragically pass beyond the Wall, the immediate absence of Benjen's guidance and leadership could have profound implications for their fate. Without his mentorship, Bran's potential as the Three-Eyed Raven would be diminished, and Meera's journey to uncover the identity of Jojen might be impeded, leading to unforeseen consequences for the war against the White Walkers.Strategic Decisions and Alternatives
Alternatively, if Benjen sticks around, the rise of Jon Snow as Lord Commander could see a shift in strategic planning. The Northern contingent, facing the threat of the White Walkers, would be more prepared under Benjen's command. Given Jon's current role, the transfer of power to Benjen could create a smoother transition in leadership, potentially allowing for better preparation and coordination of defenses.The 'Great Ranging' Revisited
The primary objective of the Great Ranging was to locate lost rangers and find Benjen Stark. Assuming the ranging proceeds, its success or failure would hinge on Benjen's personal leadership. As First Ranger, Stark would take the lead, emphasizing his experience and strategic guidance. His absence leaves the Night's Watch in a precarious position, as Mormont's refusal to delegate the responsibility to Smallwood highlights. If Benjen were to return, he could resume his role and ensure the success of the mission.Consequences for the Northern Crown
If the ranging were to continue, Rickon Stark would very likely be crowned King in the North, supported by the Umbers. With Benjen as the new Lord Commander, the North would be in a much better position to face the White Walkers. Under Benjen's leadership, the strategies and defenses of the Night's Watch could be optimized, making the North a formidable force in the war against the undead.