What If? Michael Corleone Assigns a Hit to Fredo

In 'The Godfather,' Michael Corleone's assignment of a hit is a matter of trust and capability. The hypothetical scenario of Michael ordering Fredo to kill Moe Greene due to Fredo's betrayal sets the stage for a complex narrative twist. This alternate storyline critically examines the character dynamics and the unforeseen consequences of decisions made in the face of adversity.

Michael Corleone's Understanding of Fredo

Michael Corleone, a seasoned and calculating crime boss, has a deep understanding of his brother, Fredo Corleone's, capabilities and limitations. In the film, it becomes evident that Fredo is not what one would describe as a reliable shot or a adept enforcer.

One pivotal scene where this is clearly illustrated is when their father, Vito Corleone, is attacked. Fredo, despite being the closest to their father, fumbled with his gun and was unable to defend him. This early demonstration of Fredo's inability to handle a weapon was noted by Michael, who would not assign a critical task such as a hit to such a bumbling individual. The film shows Fredo's gun dropping and his apparent lack of coordination under pressure, a testament to Michael's discernment.

The Character of Fredo

While the film portrays Fredo as a weak figure, the book offers a more nuanced view. In literature, Fredo is depicted as a cunning and sociopathic individual, capable of acting in ways that might surprise even the most experienced observer. His interactions in the movie, such as responding to a dancing girl, indicate a susceptibility to manipulation, a trait that could potentially align with the character's sociopathic tendencies.

Realities of Assigning the Hit

Michael Corleone made a significant misjudgment by trusting Freddie to remain loyal despite the high stakes in Vegas. The temptation presented by Moe Greene, a man with whom Fredo had a bro crush, was too great for him to handle. It's a reminder of the fine line between loyalty and corruption, a theme that permeates the entire 'Godfather' saga.

Alternative Route: Fredo's Potential

It is possible to hypothesize a different outcome if Michael played his cards differently. If Michael had rewarded Fredo for his loyalty and provided him with a leading role in both the family and the casino, Fredo might have felt a sense of obligation and pride in his role. However, this alternative scenario is highly speculative and contradicts both the film and the book's portrayal of Fredo's character.

Michael's failure to recognize Fredo's true nature, a decision that stemmed from Fredo's initial betrayal, sets the stage for his eventual downfall. The narrative's focus on this character flaw serves to deepen the audience's understanding of the complex web of loyalty, betrayal, and vengeance that defines the 'Godfather' universe.

Whether in the film's portrayal or the book's more intricate depiction, Fredo's actions and inactions play a pivotal role in the storyline. His inability to comply with such a crucial and dangerous task is a fundamental part of the narrative's tension and character development.

In conclusion, while it's entertaining to speculate about Michael ordering Fredo to kill Moe Greene, the real dynamics of the 'Godfather' series lie in the profound consequences of trust, betrayal, and the choices made by the powerful figures in the Corleone family.