Was Melisandre the Most Important Character in Defeating the Night King?

Throughout the thrilling battle at Winterfell in Season 8 of Game of Thrones, many characters played pivotal roles in the ultimate defeat of the Night King. Melisandre was one such crucial player, though her significance has been a subject of heated debate. This essay will delve into her contributions and the role of Arya Stark, ultimately concluding that Arya was indeed the most important character in defeating the Night King.

The Crucial Role of Melisandre

Melisandre played a significant role in the fight against the Night King. Her impact was primarily noted through her magic, belief in prophecies, and the encouragement she provided to key characters. Notably, she:

Revived Jon Snow using her magic, giving him the strength to fight against the Night King.

Believed in the prophecy of Azor Ahai, which inspired many to take up arms against the White Walkers.

Used her magic to ignite the weapons of the Dothraki, giving them a fighting chance against the White Walkers.

Encouraged Arya Stark to find her way to the Night King, emphasizing her destiny.

Melisandre’s Contribution to the Battle

Melisandre’s actions were indeed crucial, but they were often reactive or prophetic in nature. Her revival of Jon Snow and her guidance to Arya were instrumental in setting the stage for the final confrontation. Yet, the effectiveness of her magic and prophecies relied on other characters taking action. For instance, the Dothraki, despite the magic weapons, still fell victim to the Night King's army, despite the brief victory.

Arya Stark: The Central Force

While Melisandre contributed significantly in terms of preparation and encouragement, the actual defeat of the Night King was the result of Arya Stark’s actions. Arya, with the guidance of Melisandre, took action on the battlefield, marking a significant moment in the series:

Arya’s determination to kill the Night King was critical. Her final stab into the Night King's chest was the decisive act, symbolizing the breaking of the Night King’s reign of terror.

Her skills as a warrior, combined with the strategic knowledge she acquired, were instrumental in the ultimate triumph over the Night King. This was a moment of personal and collective triumph, where Arya’s efforts culminated in victory.

Conclusion: The Role of Melisandre, Arya, and the Night King

While Melisandre’s contributions were noteworthy and significant, they were often foundation laying or inspirational. Arya Stark, on the other hand, provided the direct and decisive confrontation that ended the Night King’s evil. The battle of Winterfell was a culmination of many factors, but the decisive moment in defeating the Night King can be attributed to Arya’s actions. Hence, it is accurate to say that Arya Stark was the most important character in defeating the Night King.