Was Margaery Tyrell Secretly Defying the Faith Militant?

In the intricate political arena of King's Landing, Margaery Tyrell stands out as a master tactician. Despite her public displays of piety and adherence to the Faith Militant's doctrines, there are moments that suggest a calculated defiance against the rigid tenets of the sect, especially when they threaten her family's power and the stability of the realm.

Public Persona vs. Private Struggles

Margaery exhibits exceptional intelligence and political astuteness, using her charm and influence to navigate the treacherous waters of King's Landing. Her relationships with the High Sparrow and her public displays of piety can often be seen as carefully crafted facades to protect her and her family's interests. However, her actions and strategic maneuvers indicate a level of resistance against the Faith Militant's extreme measures. For instance, her efforts to manipulate Tommen and her behind-the-scenes interactions suggest a more covert form of defiance.

Controversial Actions and Their Implications

Margaery got her freedom and satisfaction of revenge when Cersei undertook her Walk of Atonement. This success allowed her to orchestrate her escape from prison with the help of her "toyboy husband," making a deal with the religious leaders. In another instance, Margaery discreetly sent her grandmother a rose on a handkerchief, symbolizing her determination to remain independent and true to herself, despite the strict control of the Faith Militant and Cersei.

Defying the Faith Militant Quietly

Throughout the season, Margaery's interactions with the High Sparrow and the Faith Militant reveal her strategic approach in protecting her family and her position as Queen. She was the first to see the true intentions of the High Sparrow, recognizing that his mission extended beyond religious piety. By refusing to sleep with Tommen, Margaery thwarted the High Sparrow's attempt to gain power over both her child and her husband. This act of defiance was not overt but rather a calculated move to preserve her autonomy and her family’s influence.

Specific Instances of Defiance

When the High Sparrow insinuated that her grandmother, Lady Olenna Tyrell, might be in danger if she stayed in King's Landing, Margaery urged her to leave. Unbeknownst to many, Margaery assured her grandmother that she was still loyal to House Tyrell, albeit in a clandestine manner, acting with the Faith Militant to protect her family's interests. Additionally, Margaery's role in convincing Tommen to join the Faith Militant for the marriage ceremony, despite her own reservations, was more about securing her family's immediate safety and reputation than a genuine religious commitment.

Conclusion and Analysis

While Margaery does not openly defy the Faith Militant, her actions suggest a calculated and strategic approach to managing her relationship with them. This resistance emerges when the influence of the Faith Militant threatens her goals and the stability of her family. Margaery's ability to balance public piety with private defiance highlights her intelligence and strategic acumen. However, the lack of a conclusive resolution prevents us from fully understanding her final plans and intentions.