Vasquez in Aliens: A Brown Face Representation or Nuanced Character?

Vasquez, the character in the 1986 film Aliens played by actress Jenette Goldstein, has sparked considerable discussion on film representation and authenticity. While Vasquez is a strong and resilient female character who defies many stereotypes associated with women in action roles, her portrayal has raised questions about ethnic representation.

The Nuanced Discussion on Vasquez's Character

The character of Vasquez is often perceived as a Latina, given visual and stylistic cues in the film. However, Jenette Goldstein, the actress who portrays Vasquez, is of Jewish descent. This casting choice has led some critics to question the authenticity and representation in Hollywood. While Vasquez is a strong character, the casting decision has sparked debate. Critics have argued that this casting could be seen as a form of “brown face” portrayal, where a non-Latina actress is cast to play a Latina role, often using makeup to enhance the cultural appearance.

Understanding the Concept of Brown Face

The term “brown face” is used to describe a non-Latinx person putting on makeup or altering their appearance to mimic a Latinx look. Historically, this practice has been associated with acting in roles that play on stereotypes and, in some cases, can be seen as a form of subjugation and derision. However, it is important to note that the portrayal of Vasquez does not fit this description. Jacopo Teti states, “The only time that she is mocked is with the comment about her being a man and she fires back effectively at that and is clearly shown to be on top in that convo.”

Complexity of the Character

Vasquez is a complex character and a hero in the film. Despite the discussion around her ethnicity, her performance highlights her strength and skill. Goldstein's portrayal is incredibly compelling, and the character stands out as an iconic and heroic Latina, well-written by director James Cameron. Goldstein's performance is widely praised, and she is considered the standout in the ensemble cast.

The Casting Controversy

One of the criticisms is the casting choice and the casting of a non-Latina actress for a clearly Latina character. Steven Hong notes, “they should have ideally cast Jenette Elise Goldstein a Latina actress.” This concern is valid, as authenticity in representation is crucial for a more inclusive and reflective industry. The representation of Latinx characters in film has been a topic of discussion for decades, and the 1986 film Aliens reflects an earlier age where the industry was less diverse and inclusive than it is today.

Conclusion and Modern Reflections

While there is no denying the controversy around the casting of Vasquez in Aliens, the character's performance and the importance of representation cannot be overlooked. Many argue that Vasquez, despite the casting choice, is an iconic figure in Latinx representation in film. The film was groundbreaking for its time, and while modern standards may judge it differently, it is essential to remember the context in which it was made. The character of Vasquez remains an important symbol in the history of action cinema, and her performance by a non-Latina actress played a crucial role in bringing this character to life.