Unveiling the Theory: Is the High Sparrow in ‘Game of Thrones’ Actually Howland Reed?

The High Sparrow, one of the central figures in ‘Game of Thrones,’ has been a source of intrigue for many fans. The crackpot theory that he might actually be Howland Reed, the exiled crannogman, has been circulating. Let's delve into the possibility and see if there's any evidence to support this claim.

Evidence Against the Theory

One of the strongest arguments against the theory is the age of the characters. In Season 6, Episode 3, when Ned Stark and Howland Reed fought together at the Tower of Joy, both appeared to be around the same age, estimated at 50-55 years old. However, the High Sparrow, played by Patrick Stewart, appears to be well into his 70s. This significant age gap makes it highly unlikely that the High Sparrow is Howland Reed.

For a more detailed analysis, check out this YouTube video.

Appearances and Other Indicators

Another factor that might support the theory is the appearance and hairstyle of the High Sparrow. It's argued that the knotted hairstyle of the High Sparrow connects him to Meera Reed. However, it's not entirely clear that the High Sparrow is actually Howland Reed. A search through the books reveals that other characters, such as Haldon Halfmaester, Barbrey Dustin, and Obara Sand, also tie their hair back in a knot.

The High Sparrow's other features, such as his brown hair, brown eyes, and shorter stature, are more common than unusual hair colors like purple eyes and silver or gold hair. This suggests that the High Sparrow could be anyone with these features, and it's not definitive evidence that he is Howland Reed.

Religion and Faith

The High Sparrow's adherence to the Faith of the Seven might not be a significant factor to consider. Given that he's a religious leader, it's very much in line with his character to be devoted to the Faith, whether he's an impostor or not. His methods and approach to religion are distinct from his predecessors, which could be due to his recent conversion to the Faith rather than a lifelong follower.

Character Motivation and Morals

What makes the theory implausible is the lack of evidence suggesting that Howland Reed would act in the manner of the High Sparrow. The High Sparrow's actions in A Dance with Dragons, where he shows a rigid and rigidly-followed faith, are in stark contrast to Howland Reed's history. There's no indication that Howland Reed would have had the same zealotry and willingness to harm others as the High Sparrow.

From Robb Stark's and the young Reeds' perspectives, even if Howland Reed had personally cut off Eddard Stark's head, there's no mention of him showing the ruthless and cunning tendencies seen in the High Sparrow. The High Sparrow is described as an angry zealot, which is far from Howland Reed's character as we know him.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while the theory that the High Sparrow might be Howland Reed is an intriguing one, the available evidence and in-depth analysis from the show’s narrative and books suggest that it is highly unlikely. The significant age gap between the High Sparrow and Howland Reed, as well as their distinct character traits and motivations, make the connection implausible. It remains a fascinating point of curiosity for fans, but from a realistic standpoint, it's more likely that the High Sparrow is a different character altogether.

References

Game of Thrones Season 6, Episode 3 Director's commentary on the DVD Books: A Dance with Dragons