Unveiling the Plot Holes in the Fourth Season of Sherlock

The fourth season of Sherlock, despite its initial promise, is often criticized for its numerous plot holes and inconsistencies. Fans of the show, particularly those who have caught every episode meticulously, have pointed out several glaring errors. In this article, we'll explore some of the most notable mistakes and discuss how they might have been avoided.

Missing Phone During the Moriarty Reveal

While the buildup for the return of Moriarty was indeed thrilling, the reveal at the end of Series 3 left fans disappointed. One of the major inconsistencies is the disappearance of Mrs. Hudson's phone during this significant moment. In the episode, while Watson and Sherlock are dealing with a hostage situation, they hear a woman's moan and immediately know it's Mrs. Hudson. However, when the situation is resolved and Mrs. Hudson finally appears, she seems to be holding the phone. This oversight might have been avoided if the production team had ensured the phone was visible in the earlier scenes or had taken it out of the shot.

Sign of Three Subplot: The Bloody Guardsman

The subplot The Sign of Three: The Bloody Mendleton Guard presents another critical mistake. In the fictional story, a criminal is stabbed by the guards and it is held that his belt is preventing him from bleeding. However, this logic fails when considering the timeline. A person stabbed in such a manner would have started bleeding almost immediately, especially in a shower. The spilled blood would have created a significant mess on the floor, which the character would have likely experienced while attempting to reach the shower, potentially before losing consciousness due to blood loss. This inconsistency is a disappointment in a plot that is usually characterized by its meticulous attention to detail.

URL Error in Computer Screenshots

A small but noticeable error can be found in the first two episodes of Series 1. During Sherlock and John's investigation, the screen often displays a URL that simply doesn't exist on the internet. The URL in question is C:httponline-news, which clearly indicates a locally stored HTML page rather than a functional website. This mistake is frustrating, especially because such a simple oversight could have been corrected by ensuring the URL was changed or the relevant portions cropped. The production team may have overlooked this detail in their enthusiasm for the complex plot.

Room Rotation in Slow Motion

In another scene, Sherlock falls back to stop blood flow, and the room rotates in slow motion. Paying close attention to this sequence, one notices that the flower vase falls during the rotation. This defies the laws of physics unless the directing team used a special effect, which was not evident in the final scene. This detail, while a minor error, distracts from the otherwise well-constructed storyline.

Conclusion

While Sherlock is generally praised for its quality and attention to detail, the fourth season does not escape criticism. These errors may seem minor, but they highlight the importance of thorough reviewing and consideration in the production process. Fans and critics alike can now enjoy or dissect these plot holes, adding a layer of depth to the already rich Sherlock experience.

Keywords: Sherlock mistakes, TV series plot holes, Sherlock season 4 errors