Unveiling the Mystery of Fake Arya in Game of Thrones

In the complex and intricate world of Game of Thrones, it often becomes challenging to distinguish between the original characters and their imitations. One such mystery revolves around the question, 'Who is the fake Arya?' This article delves into the enigmatic Waif and explores the theories surrounding her identity. By examining evidence and drawing parallels, we aim to uncover the truth behind who the Waif really is and whether she is a manifestation of Jeyne Poole's vengeance.

The Waif's Identity: Mysterious and Challenging

Throughout the series, there was no reason for Arya Stark to have shown such malevolence towards The Waif. However, it was revealed that The Waif is not who she claims to be. Instead, she is another person entirely, and Arya herself is the one who killed her in the sewers of Braavos. The Waif then took Arya's identity and assumed it for herself. This revelation adds a layer of mystery and complexity to Arya's character and her actions in the subsequent episodes.

One of the key pieces of evidence that supports this theory is the strong physical reaction Arya had when mentioning the Freys. The Waif, on the other hand, seems to have a deep-seated hatred towards Arya. This contradictory behavior suggests that the Waif may have had a personal vendetta against Arya, possibly rooted in her past experiences.

Connecting the Dots: The Waif and Jeyne Poole

There are several theories that suggest Jeyne Poole could be the real Waif. Jeyne Poole, a former servant at Riverrun, had a tumultuous relationship with Arya and Sansa. Her father and other relatives were killed during the Red Wedding, orchestrated by the Freys and House Lannister, which is a significant event in Westeros. As a result, Jeyne Poole could harbor a deep-seated hatred towards the Freys, Lannisters, and even the Starks, given their role in her family's tragic fate.

Jeyne Poole's personal trauma and loss could explain her intense malice towards Sansa. The two girls were best friends during their childhood, which makes Jeyne Poole's sudden hatred and animosity even more troubling. This theory adds a layer of depth and tragedy to the storyline, portraying Jeyne Poole as a victim of circumstances who is now seeking revenge.

Supporting evidence for this theory includes:

Before the "showdown" scene between Arya and the Waif, Arya is left-handed. However, after this scene, her hand preference changes to right-handed, suggesting a major shift in her 's demeanor changes after the encounter. She begins to carry herself with a similar posture to the Waif, further indicating a transformation in her most compelling evidence comes from the fact that the Waif doesn't need to cut Arya's face since she is already dead. Instead, Arya would need to cut the Waif's face to establish her new identity. This detail underscores the reality of the situation.

Moreover, the Waif's knowledge of Hot Pie, a baker mentioned in the series, is a puzzle. However, this can be explained by the capabilities of the Faceless Men, who are known to take on various identities and even memories. This supernatural element aligns with the overall theme of the show and the abilities of the Faceless Men.

The Waif's Motive: Revenge Against the Stark Family

Considering Jeyne Poole's past and the events leading up to her assumed identity as the Waif, it is clear that her main motive is to seek revenge against House Stark. The Waif's hatred towards the Starks can be attributed to their perceived role in the deaths of her family and friends during the Red Wedding. The Waif's plan appears to be centered around exacting vengeance on the Starks, particularly Sansa Stark, who was once a close friend.

This theory not only provides a plausible explanation for the Waif's actions but also adds a new dimension to the ongoing conflicts in the series. It suggests that the Waif is not just a random killer, but a form of justice for a tragic loss that some considered justifiable, now transformed into a twisted vendetta.

In conclusion, the mystery of the Waif in Game of Thrones remains deeply rooted in the complex web of identities and destinies in the series. Jeyne Poole's theory not only offers a compelling explanation for the Waif's identity but also adds a tragic backstory to her character. As the series progresses, we can anticipate more revelations and plot twists that will continue to unravel this intricate mystery.