Unrealistic Elements in The Huntsman: Winter's War (2016)

The Huntsman: Winters War, a 2016 film directed by Charles Sturridge and starring Chris Hemsworth, Kristen Stewart, Charlize Theron, and Emily Blunt, is a prime example of a movie that prioritized spectacle over substance. While the film is visually stunning, it is hampered by an overly convoluted and illogical plot that fails to deliver on its promises of engaging action and compelling character development.

Unrealism from the Start

From the very first seconds, The Huntsman: Winters War introduces elements that exist purely for the sake of storytelling rather than realism. The movie, which resides in the fantasy realm, is designed to entertain rather than adhere to the rules of real-world logic. The concept of a sister, Freya (played by Emily Blunt), possessing ice powers simply because of her genetic inheritance is a gross simplification that should have been avoided.

Historically, magical powers based on genetic inheritance do not exist, making this a significant point of disbelief. Moreover, the narrative framework of the film, a prequel and sequel hybrid, feels unnecessary. With each new installment, it seems like filmmakers are compelled to add new plot twists and characters, rather than developing the existing ones.

Illogical Plot and Action Sequences

The film's script is riddled with improbable plot devices. Logic is largely absent, and the narrative often feels like a sketchpad for throwing in elements for spectacle's sake. For instance, the scene where Freya uses a trebuchet as a personal weapon against cavalry troops is absurd and historically inaccurate. Trebuchets were designed for sieges and to bring down castle walls, not for mobile combat. Similarly, the cavalry assailing a castle with charges seems more reminiscent of a mythological tale than a realistic military strategy.

Throughout the film, fight scenes are choreographed for visual impact rather than plausibility. The airy script and direction contribute to a sense of detachment from the real world, making the battle sequences feel staged and unrealistic. Viewers are likely to find themselves questioning the logic behind certain events, which detracts from the overall enjoyment of the movie.

Below-Par Acting and Script Issues

While the film has visual appeal, the acting and script present significant challenges. For instance, Jessica Chastain, who is known for her powerful screen presence, struggles to find meaningful dimensions in her role. Her portrayal of Freya is one-dimensional and lacks the depth required to engage the audience on an emotional level. This issue is compounded by the script, which seems to be a mishmash of written sentences instead of a coherent story.

Given that The Huntsman: Winters War is a fantasy film, viewers expect the performances to be more campy or over-the-top. However, the performances fall short of this expectation, often appearing wooden and forced. Kristen Stewart and Charlize Theron, as well, do not deliver the punch they are capable of in other roles, making it difficult to root for their characters.

Conclusion

The Huntsman: Winters War is a prime example of a film that prioritizes visual spectacle over narrative coherence. While the cinematography and special effects are commendable, the story and character development fall short, leaving viewers with a sense of dissatisfaction. The film's reliance on unrealistic plot devices and lack of engaging character arcs make it a curious exercise in camp and spectacle. For those who can look past the logical fallacies and adherence to realism, the film provides a visually stunning viewing experience. However, for the discerning audience member, it is a cautionary tale about the pitfalls of sacrificing substance for style.