Unpopular Opinions on J.R.R. Tolkien's Works: Debating Canon, Influence, and Moving Beyond Tradition

Tolkien's The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings have enthralled fans for decades, but beneath the surface of beloved tales lies a rich tapestry of influences and debates that don't always align with the popular viewpoint. In this article, we delve into some unpopular opinions regarding Tolkien's works and explore the nuances that some scholars and readers disagree with.

Canon vs. Earlier Influences

When discussing The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, the concept of "canon" often emerges. However, many overlook the significant influence that earlier authors had on Tolkien. For instance, he drew heavily from the works of George MacDonald, particularly evident in the Princess and Curdie. The flow of events in The Battle of the Five Armies mirrors the final battle in The Princess and Curdie, a detail that many Tolkien fans dismiss as impossible.

The Ring Quest vs. External Intervention

Another unpopular opinion is the assertion that the quest to destroy the One Ring could have been accomplished by eagles, much like Switzerland's Saint Bernards. Critics argue that such a notion undermines the depth of the quest's gravity, suggesting that external intervention would trivialize the moral and spiritual journey of its characters. Tolkien himself believed that the success of the quest relied on the integrity and humility of the individuals involved, particularly on characters like Sam and Faramir.

Elves in Tolkien's Universe

The portrayal of Elves in Tolkien's works often raises debate. In The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, Elves are depicted more as traditional fairy tale characters, sometimes mischievous and adorable. However, in the Silmarillion, Tolkien paints a more complex picture. Elves are divided into varying extremes of courage, power, and radiant grace, with some individuals still prone to both magnanimity and malice. By contrast, the Elves of the Third Age are portrayed as more restrained and reflective, embodying the weariness of experience.

Adaptation and Coherence

The transition from written to visual adaptation often elicits mixed reactions. Filmed versions of Tolkien's works are frequently criticized for their deviation from the original source material, with some purists arguing that the essence of the story is lost. However, this criticism overlooks the fact that adaptations must convey the story's themes to modern audiences through coherent characters and plot lines. Examples like The Wizard of Oz, Sherlock Holmes, and Gone With the Wind demonstrate how successful adaptations can reinterpret traditional narratives without sacrificing their soul.

Hierarchy and Value in Tolkien's Legendarium

Tolkien's depiction of hierarchy is another point of contention. His works often reflect traditional values that may seem outdated in today's context. For instance, the treatment of younger hobbits, the racial hierarchy, and the roles of women in The Lord of the Rings might be seen as problematic from a modern standpoint. While these elements offer a glimpse into the author's personal values and the conventions of his time, it is essential to recognize them as pieces of a larger tapestry rather than absolute truths.

Final Thoughts

Whether you're a staunch fan or a critical reader, there's much to appreciate and debate in J.R.R. Tolkien's works. While some opinions may be unpopular, they offer valuable insights into the layers of influence, adaptation, and cultural context that shape these beloved stories. By examining these perspectives, we can deepen our appreciation of Tolkien's legacy and the enduring power of his imagination.