Understanding the Return of Dothraki and Jorah Mormont in Game of Thrones S8E03: A Study in Battle Tactics and Survival

In the highly anticipated finale of Game of Thrones, Season 8 Episode 3, the viewers are presented with a pivotal moment that showcases the chaos and brutal realities of war. Why do a few Dothraki and Jorah Mormont return from the first charge? This article delves into the strategic and survival aspects that drive these characters' actions in the midst of battle.

Survival Instinct: A Fundamental Motive

The first and most basic reason for the return of some Dothraki and Jorah Mormont from the initial charge is survival instinct. In the intense and overwhelming face-off against the army of the undead, not all Dothraki were caught in the initial wave. Some may have managed to retreat or find a way to escape the mass of approaching wights. Survival is the most primal urge, and without it, very little else can be accomplished. This instinct drives individuals to escape danger whenever possible, ensuring their own survival for further engagement in the battle.

Leadership and Strategic Acumen: Jorah’s Influence

Jorah Mormont’s presence of mind and battle experience played a significant role in the decision of those who returned. As a seasoned warrior, Jorah likely recognized that the situation had become dire and needed immediate attention. The ability to regroup and fall back when necessary is a critical trait in battle, one that separates leaders from mere participants. Jorah’s leadership and strategic thinking allowed him to navigate the retreat and regroupment for a strategic advantage in the future.

Positioning and Battle Dynamics

The initial positioning of the Dothraki charge is also crucial in understanding why some returned. The charge was designed to create a shock effect and intimidate the enemy, but not all Dothraki were in the forefront of this charge. Those not in the front lines, or who quickly realized the futility of the initial charge, may have chosen to retreat. This strategic positioning highlights the importance of adaptability and situational awareness in battle. Tactical responses vary depending on the phase of the battle and the evolving conditions.

The Reality of Heavy Cavalry Operations

Heavy cavalry, like those described in historical records, typically exhibit a charge-retreat-reform cycle. They charge, engage in combat, and then retreat to reform for a second charge, possibly switching horses. This cycle allows for the consolidation of forces and the reorganization of strategic positions. However, in the dothraki charge in Game of Thrones, the situation was drastically different. The overwhelming losses sustained during the first charge made it impossible for most Dothraki to regroup and attempt a second charge. This highlights the infeasibility of traditional heavy cavalry tactics in face of an overwhelming force that had the ability to rise from the dead.

Survival and Pragmatism: Jorah and Survivors

For Jorah and the few Dothraki who managed to retreat, the decision to leave the initial charge was not a sign of weakness but rather a demonstration of pragmatism and survival. The brutal and foolish nature of the initial charge was quickly apparent as it incurred heavy losses almost instantly. Recognizing this, Jorah and the remaining Dothraki who retreated could see that continuing the charge would be futile. Their choice to retreat and regroup increases their chances of survival and allows for a more strategic engagement later.

Conclusion

The return of some Dothraki and Jorah Mormont from the first charge in Game of Thrones Season 8 Episode 3 is a testament to survival instinct, leadership, and adaptability. While the initial charge was designed to create shock and intimidate, the harsh realities of the battle with an overwhelming force forced many to retreat. The strategic and survival-driven actions of Jorah and the survivors highlight the complexities of battle and the importance of adaptability and pragmatism.