Understanding Hermione’s Decision to Howl Like a Wolf in Harry Potter
H earsay and Emma Watson couldn't have deliberately planned Hermione's howling like a wolf in a Harry Potter movie scene? Many believe this sequence was a director's decision, but let's unpack the reasoning behind this action. In the Professor and the Monster, Hermione's cry as a wolf was a deliberate storyline addition that aligned with the narrative and script.
Why Hermione Howled Like a Wolf to Save Past Harry and Hermione
The scene where Hermione howls like a wolf to prevent a werewolf from attacking past-Harry and past-Hermione is a pivotal moment that showcases her quick thinking and the challenges of acting under pressure. Hermione, realizing that a werewolf is only drawn to the cry of its own kind, had to act swiftly, though her decision to do so without fully considering all consequences was indeed reckless.
It's important to note that all of these characters, including Hermione, are thirteen-year-olds during the filming of the movie. It is highly unlikely that they could have had any significant input into the film's plot. The decision to have her howl like a wolf was pre-scripted and part of the meticulous planning by the movie's director and screenwriter.
Thirteen-Year-Olds in a Dangerous Situation
Hermione, along with Harry, finds themselves in a perilous situation when a werewolf, Remus Lupin in his werewolf form, is charging at them. The immediate decision she makes—honing in on the werewolf's sensitivity to the cry of its own kind—is an example of her limited thought process in high-stress situations. Reflecting on this scene, it appears that her rationale was based on the established rule that a werewolf would respond to the call of its own kind, which was introduced during one of the DADA classes taught by Severus Snape.
Why the Scene Was Changed in the Movie
Another point of interest is the brevity of the scene as compared to what could be a more detailed in-film discussion. The original script likely included a more drawn-out discussion between Hermione, Harry, and perhaps even Ron. However, due to the already lengthy runtime of the film, the decision was made to condense the dialogue and action for better pacing and clarity. This change wasn't arbitrary but rather a strategic choice made to maintain the film's narrative flow and viewer engagement.
Hermione’s Quick Thinking and Recklessness
Hermione's howl, though reckless and potentially perilous, was valiant and critical in the moment. She understood that her action could save her friends from a dire fate. In a life-or-death scenario, her rapid decision-making, while not perfectly calculated, demonstrated her character's notable and commendable qualities. Her decision underscores her bravery and quick thinking, which are traits that endear her to readers and viewers alike.
Concluding, the decision to have Hermione howl like a wolf in the Harry Potter movie was a carefully crafted script element, making it a deliberate and essential part of the storyline. This quirky yet significant moment reflects the narrative's need to address the werewolf's unique trait and the characters' shared struggle to protect each other from a dangerous past.
Cheerio!