Understanding Brienne of Tarth’s Treatment of Podrick Payne in 'Game of Thrones'

In the Game of Thrones series, the relationship between Brienne of Tarth and Podrick Payne has often been a subject of discussion and interpretation. It is commonly perceived that Brienne was mean to Podrick, but this characterization is quite complex and multifaceted. Let’s delve into the reasons behind Brienne's demeanor towards Podrick and explore her evolving relationship with him.

Initial Perception and Protective Instincts

When Brienne of Tarth first meets Podrick Payne in Duskendale, she appears apprehensive about him. This initial reaction is influenced by several factors. Firstly, Podrick is related to Ilyn Payne, who is a member of the King’s Justice, and he serves as a squire to Tyrion Lannister. This connection might have led to an initial mistrust or caution.

Brienne is known for her strong sense of honor and duty. She expects others to live up to these high standards. This expectation can result in her being critical of those who do not meet these standards. Moreover, she is fiercely protective of those she cares about, and this nascent relationship with Podrick necessitates a toughening process to prepare him for the challenges they face together on their journey.

Exploring Personal Struggles and Character Development

Brienne's treatment of Podrick reflects her own personal struggles. In a world that often dismisses her due to her gender and appearance, she might project her frustrations and insecurities onto Podrick. This projection is especially evident since Podrick is in a subordinate position. Over time, however, Brienne's attitude towards Podrick evolves, and she comes to appreciate his loyalty and bravery. This evolution from initial harshness to mutual respect and camaraderie is a significant aspect of their developing relationship.

Medieval Swordplay and Training Methods

It is important to note that during medieval times, being "mean" in terms of physical training was a common practice. Swordplay training was often rigorous and harsh. In the series, we see similar methods of training, such as the training of Samwell Tarly at Castle Black and Hornhill, where his instructor was Randylltown. The beatings and sparring sessions between Brienne and Podrick were a part of the rigorous training that prepares them for the dangers they face together.

When the protagonists are about to be hanged by the Brotherhood Without Banners, a significant moment of understanding and mutual respect is portrayed. Brienne is seen begging the outlaws to leave Podrick and Hyle alone, indicating her regard for Podrick and the importance of preserving his life and dignity.

Conclusion

Brienne of Tarth's treatment of Podrick Payne in 'Game of Thrones' is nuanced and complex. It is rooted in her expectations of duty, her protective instincts, and the harsh realities of medieval training. The evolving nature of their relationship from initial critique to mutual respect showcases the deep connection and growth they share throughout their journey together.