Thor vs. Hulk: A Battle of Giants in the Marvel Universe

The rivalry between Thor and Hulk is one of the most iconic and enduring in the Marvel Comics universe. These two behemoths of strength and power have faced each other on countless battlefields, both in the comics and in popular culture. Despite their many clashes, the outcomes of their battles are far from clear-cut, a testament to their strength and complexity.

ID: 1 - Comprehensive Overview

Overall, Thor has emerged victorious 15 times in documented encounters, according to various publications. This tally includes battles that showcase both heroes' strengths and the complex nature of their rivalry. Here is a detailed breakdown of some key encounters:

Avengers #3 (1964): In one of the earliest documented fights, Thor and Hulk clash. However, their battle is interrupted, leaving their outcome unclear and highlighting the unpredictability of their encounters. Mighty Thor #73 (2011): Writer Mark Waid culminates this series with a dramatic confrontation where Thor overpowers Hulk. Despite Hulk's previous knocks, Thor's ultimate victory is conclusive. Thor: Ragnarok (2017): The film depicts Thor defeating Hulk in a gladiatorial setting, reinforcing his combat prowess and further victories over his adversary. Infernal Hulk Annual #15 (2001): In a story where Hulk lays waste to Thor, the hammer was used as a weapon, giving Hulk the upper hand. This makes it a close call but unofficially counts as one win for Hulk.

ID: 2 - Hulk's Victories

Counting the victories, Hulk boasts four wins over Thor, depending on your criteria for a 'win.'

Infernal Hulk Annual #15 (2001): Hulk lays waste to Thor, making it one win for him. Mighty Thor #385 (1987): Hulk even the score, making it a draw at this point. Infernal Hulk #227 (2006): Hulk again edges Thor, giving him another win. Immortal Hulk #7 (2018): Here, Devil Hulk beats "Aaron Newton's Thor," confirming another victory for the green giant.

In total, Hulk emerges victorious over Thor in four instances if you count bouts where he deals critical blows, while Thor has thirty-five wins under the same conditions.

ID: 3 - Tallying the Battles

With over 60 encounters between Thor and Hulk, both heroes have left an indelible mark on the Marvel universe. Here are a few notable battles to illustrate their complex relationship:

Avengers #3 (1964): An early encounter that ended in an inconclusive battle. Journey Into Mystery #112 (1962): Another fight that remains unresolved. The Incredible Hulk #255 (1984): A fierce battle that ends with Thor overcoming Hulk. The Avengers #5 (1968): This fight is marked by a close and evenly matched contest.

Despite the vast number of battles, only a handful can be definitively counted as victories for either hero, underscoring the unpredictable and dynamic nature of their encounters.

ID: 4 - Respect and Balance

The ultimate tally is as follows:

Hulk wins 2 times (including unofficial counts). Thor wins 3 times.

Though the numbers are close, the battles between Thor and Hulk are far from definitive. The outcome often depends on the narrative context and the creativity of the writer. As such, it's essential to appreciate both heroes equally for their strength, bravery, and mutual respect in the Marvel universe.

VERDICT: Hulk has 2 wins against Thor, while Thor narrowly edges him out with 3 wins. Respect both Thor and Hulk, the real tanks of the Marvel universe!