The Throne Claim After the Death of Key Characters: Gendry's Contention

It's a debatable topic as to who gets the last say when Jon Snow, Daenerys Targaryen, and Cersei Lannister die in the highly contentious and intricate plotlines of A Song of Ice and Fire series. This article explores the potential claimants, specifically focusing on Gendry, and determines whether he has the strongest case for the Iron Throne.

Legitimacy and Dispute

The Game of Thrones world revolves around the right of conquest and disputed claims. In the absence of Viserys Targaryen, Jon Snow emerged as one of the most obvious potential claimants. Interestingly, one could reveal a secret marriage and remarry under certain circumstances, which could make their claim more valid. However, convincing the Faith and nobility of such an arrangement would be a monumental challenge.

Contenders for the Throne

The list of potential claimants is extensive. Apart from Jon, Daenerys Targaryen, and Gendry, other characters like Edric Storm and Val (nicknamed fAegon) also have claims. Should Stannis Baratheon and his daughter Shireen fall, the legitimate Baratheon line would indeed be nullified. Even if the illegitimate Baratheons gather sufficient military support, the nobility's acceptance is highly improbable.

Pros and Cons of Each Claimant

Daenerys Targaryen: Although no one disputes her legitimacy, her claim remains tenuous due to her gender. The Seven Kingdoms traditionally favors male reign, a fact that could undermine her rights to the throne. fAegon Targaryen: If genuine, he would have the strongest claim. However, doubts about his parentage will likely arise, much like the historical figure False Dmitry. Jon Snow: His father was Rhaegar and he is a man, which could positively impact his claim. Yet, his legitimacy would still be questioned by those who opposed his mother and Rhaegar's marriage. Gendry: Originally a bastard, Gendry's father might be Robert Baratheon. His claim, while less well-known and strongly contested, could gain momentum if he is proven to be the son of Robert.

Right of Conquest Looms Large

The real deciding factor in the Game of Thrones world is not bloodline but military power and political maneuvering. Aerys II, who lost the throne by right of conquest, sets a precedent that continues with Robert Baratheon and his heirs. If Aegon I could win the Iron Throne by waging war, Roberts and his successors must do the same or lose it. Hence, none of the contenders have a claim unless they can build a formidable army and conquer the Seven Kingdoms.

No Rightful King

Even if someone manages to claim the throne, it may not be recognized as the "rightful" king or queen. Considering that the claims of the Targaryens and Baratheons, both legitimate and illegitimate, have been challenged and overturned, any new claimant would similarly be subject to dispute. The system itself is flawed, making it difficult to determine a rightful monarch.

Ultimately, the outcome of the succession battle will depend on who can amass the strongest army and wield the most political savvy to bring their claim to light and power. The honor of who truly deserves the Iron Throne, if such a concept exists, boils down to the will and strength of those vying for it, rather than the legitimacy of their line.