The Worst Plot Point in a Great TV Show: A Case Study of Game of Thrones
The Worst Plot Point in a Great TV Show: A Case Study of Game of Thrones
While many TV shows are celebrated for their intricate plots and well-developed characters, every once in a while, a plot point emerges that stands out as particularly egregious. In this article, we will focus on one such instance in the beloved series, Game of Thrones. The episode in question involves the Arya Stark killing the Night King, sparking a debate about plot consistency and character integrity.
Setting the Stage: The Legacy of Game of Thrones
Game of Thrones, like any great series, was built on its complex characters and intricate plot twists. Fans around the world have become deeply invested in its characters, often holding their story arcs to a high standard. At its best, the show offers a dynamic portrayal of key characters, such as Arya Stark, who undergo a significant journey of growth and transformation.
Character Development and Plot Hole: Arya and the Night King
Arya Stark’s character arc is one of the most compelling journeys in the show, marked by her loss and subsequent quest for vengeance. The narrative often ties Arya’s storyline to the looming threat of the White Walkers and the Night King. However, one scene in particular raises serious questions about the show’s narrative consistency and character motivation: Arya’s killing of the Night King in “The Long Night”.
Unlike other major characters such as Jon Snow, Arya has consistently been portrayed as more focused on her personal vendettas rather than the broader war being waged by the Night King. Throughout the series, her primary motivation has been avenging her family, much of which occurs off-screen. This sudden shift in her character’s sole focus to the Night King creates a significant plot hole, suggesting an inconsistency in her motivations and character development.
The Role of Jon Snow in the Night King's Dilemma
Teenager Jon Snow, on the other hand, has been ingrained in the Night King narrative from the beginning. In contrast to Arya, Jon’s character has been shown fighting and dodging the White Walkers for nearly the entire series. His “hardway” episode, “Hardhome,” not only promised a pivotal fight between Jon and the Night King but also provided a dramatic turning point. Yet, in taking the Night King down, the show seemingly forgot about the specific battle scene it had set up, leaving fans feeling let down and confused.
Other characters like Daenerys Targaryen, Samwell Tarly, and Jaime Lannister are also excellent choices for taking down the Night King, each providing unique storylines and motivations. For instance, Daenerys’ struggle with fire and ice would have made for a symbolic and fitting demise. Meanwhile, Samwell’s knowledge of the White Walker threat could have offered a strategic advantage, adding depth to the storyline.
The Option of Theon Greyjoy's Redemption
In the world of Game of Thrones, Theon Greyjoy represents a deeply resonant character who has been trying to find redemption since his arc began. His story of pain and learning is one of the most poignant in the series. Integrating Theon into the fight against the Night King would have been a powerful conclusion to his character arc. Standing against the Night King with a sword through his chest, he could have fulfilled both his personal quest and contributed to the series’ overarching narrative.
Conclusion: A Reflection on Character Arcs
The best characters are those who grow and evolve over the course of a series, facing challenges that continue to develop and challenge them. In Game of Thrones, the character arcs of Arya Stark, Jon Snow, and Theon Greyjoy offer a range of compelling possibilities that the show could have explored with greater depth. While it is natural for TV shows to occasionally falter, these inconsistencies in the narrative can help us refine what creates truly impactful storytelling.
Key Takeaways
Character development plays a crucial role in maintaining narrative consistency. Prominent battles and plot points should be meticulously planned and executed. Exploring multiple character options can lead to more satisfying storytelling.By critically examining the narrative choices made in Game of Thrones, we can gain a deeper appreciation for the challenges faced by writers and directors in crafting a cohesive and engaging story.