The Use of Modern Music in Period Pieces: The Case of 'American Horror Story: Freakshow'

When we think of period pieces, such as American Horror Story: Freakshow, set in 1952, the expectation is typically for a soundtrack that complements the historical setting. However, the show's decision to incorporate a modern song like 'Gods and Monsters,' featuring lyrics about Jim Morrison, surprisingly challenges this expectation. This article delves into the reasoning behind this choice, examining the potential parallels with meta-shows and the influence of modern soundtracks in horror.

Why Use Modern Music in 'Freakshow'?

Period pieces, like American Horror Story, aim to present a cohesive and historically accurate narrative. The inclusion of modern music can be jarring, breaking the immersion for viewers. However, 'Freakshow' deliberately retains modern musical elements, which can serve multiple purposes. This choice allows the show to explore themes of historical legacy and cultural relevance.

Encouraging Reflection on Real-life History

The song 'Gods and Monsters' by Pete Doherty marks a significant moment in the show, invoking the life and cultural impact of Jim Morrison. This is not just a random choice of music; it serves as a powerful narrative device to reflect on real-life history. By including a modern sound in a setting where one might expect traditional period pieces, the show prompts viewers to reconsider and integrate contemporary narratives with historical facts.

Meta-Narrative and Inter-textuality

The broad scope of American Horror Story allows for a meta-narrative, where the show comments on itself and its own production. The inclusion of modern music in a historical setting, such as 'Gods and Monsters' in 'Freakshow,' can be interpreted as a form of meta-commentary. This meta-narrative aspect might suggest that the show is aware of and engaging with its audience in a purposeful way.

Modern Soundtracks in Horror Films

There is a long-standing trend in horror films to feature modern soundtracks. Examples include:

The 4/5 time music in Halloween the epic soundtrack of The Lost Boys the spine-chilling sound of The Exorcist modern covers played in Yellowjackets

These soundtracks enhance the horror elements of the movies, making the fear more palpable and emotional. Similarly, 'Freakshow' uses modern music to heighten the emotional and psychological tension of the story, thereby creating a more immersive and intense viewing experience.

Conclusion

The decision to include a modern song in a period piece like 'Freakshow' is a deliberate choice that serves both thematic and narrative purposes. It reflects on historical events through a contemporary lens and engages with the meta-narrative of the show. Whether it is a meta-show or a carefully curated soundtrack, the inclusion of modern music in 'Freakshow' adds another layer to the already rich and multifaceted story.