The Unlikelihood of Star Trek: Discovery Being a Section 31 Ship

For many fans of Star Trek, the theory that Star Trek: Discovery actually depicts the secretive Section 31 has gained considerable traction. However, a detailed analysis of the show reveals several inconsistencies that make this theory highly improbable.

An Open and Transparent Starfleet

Season 2 of Star Trek: Discovery presents a stark contrast to any Section 31 involvement. Throughout the season, references to Section 31 are prevalent, with virtually every character in Starfleet seemingly aware of their existence. Additionally, Section 31 even places a liaison officer on the Discovery, an action that goes against established Star Trek canon in numerous ways.

The conflict between the current storyline and well-established canon becomes apparent when we consider that a covert organization like Section 31, with a specific mandate to operate outside the normal parameters of Starfleet, would never have been able to maintain such a public and overt presence. Section 31's very nature lies in its secrecy and ability to operate without detection. The Discovery being a visible and operated Section 31 ship is highly implausible given the level of oversight and scrutiny in Starfleet.

Characters and Their Actions

Striking a balance between the newly introduced characters and their actions and established Star Trek characters like Benjamin Sisko and James Kirk, it becomes evident that the characters in Discovery are far too open and transparent to be associated with Section 31. For instance, Michael Burnham, despite not caring much for rules, is not portrayed in a way that suggests she is part of this covert organization. Similarly, Discovery's actions and command crew are too visible and operationally transparent to align with the covert operating style of Section 31.

Evidence and Absence of Proof

There is no concrete evidence, whether in scenes, dialogues, or context, that supports the idea that Section 31 is involved in Star Trek: Discovery. Captain Lorca, while operating with questionable ethics, aligns more with the methods of characters like Sisko. Michael Burnham's disregard for rules is more akin to Kirk's disregard, albeit with a different perspective. Despite the dubious behavior of certain characters, there is no direct indication that they belong to Section 31 or that this secret organization is providing their cover.

Contradictions and Continuity Issues

The idea that Section 31 could be at the center of a new Star Trek series seems unreasonable, given that the character of Section 31 is primarily designed to contrast with the ideals of the true Starfleet. For instance, Dr. Bashir, a character who is initially suspicious of Section 31, ultimately rejects them and works towards their downfall. This character arc provides a strong indication that Section 31 is not the central theme of the series.

Moreover, contradictions and oddities in the continuity of Star Trek: Discovery lead us to question whether the series is set in the Prime Timeline. Theories involving alternate timelines and parallel universes are consistent with the unconventional storyline of Discovery. The resolution of these contradictions and the return to a more familiar version of the Star Trek universe might be the ultimate answer to the questions raised by the series.

A Comparative Analysis with The Orville

While Star Trek: Discovery has its flaws, it is worth noting that shows like The Orville, which is often criticized for not aligning with classic Star Trek tropes, have managed to capture the essence of Starfleet in a more relatable and humorous manner. This comparison further underscores the belief that Section 31 is not the central theme of Discovery.

Based on the evidence presented, it is reasonable to conclude that the idea of Star Trek: Discovery being a Section 31 ship is a theory that stretches the boundaries of established canon too far. The storyline, characters, and overall narrative of the series suggest a different direction entirely, one that is more consistent with the ideals and ethos of Starfleet.