The Underrated Stars of Western Cinema: Lee Van Cleef, Harry Carey Jr., and Montgomery Clift

Western cinema has a rich history filled with iconic figures who carved out their own niches in the genre. However, among the names that are often overshadowed by more prominent figures like John Wayne and Clint Eastwood, three standout actors stand out: Lee Van Cleef, Harry Carey Jr., and Montgomery Clift. Each of these actors brought their unique talents to the forefront of the Western genre, leaving an indelible mark on the craft.

Lee Van Cleef: The Perfect Western Outlaw

Led by Lee Van Cleef, who appeared in over 170 films including classics like High Noon and The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly, this actor perfectly embodied the essence of a Western outlaw. Despite his undeniable talent and extensive body of work, Van Cleef remains underappreciated when compared to contemporaries such as John Wayne and Clint Eastwood. His perfect persona and distinctive angular features set him apart in the Western genre, yet he has not received his due recognition. The question remains: why is he not mentioned in the same breath as his more celebrated peers?

Harry Carey Jr.: A Legacy of Heroism

Harry Carey Jr., the son of silent film legend Harry Carey, was a prominent figure in both Western and non-Western films. Following his father's footsteps, he became one of the earliest superstars of silent cinema, often cast as a Western hero. In a symbolism that resonates deeply, actor John Wayne himself paid homage to Carey in the closing shot of The Searchers (1956), imitating a stance Carey often used. This reference not only highlighted the legacy of silent film but also underscored the impact of Harry Carey's work on Hollywood.

One of Carey Jr.'s most notable performances was as the president of the United States Senate in the 1939 film Mr. Smith Goes to Washington. This role earned him a nomination for the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor. Moreover, he carried on his father's legacy by becoming a prominent actor in his own right. Harry Carey Jr.'s career spanned decades, from his first appearance in a film in 1908 to his last in 1972. His rugged frame and craggy features made him a perfect fit for Westerns and outdoor adventures, and his assured gritty baritone voice only added to his on-screen presence.

Montgomery Clift: A Master Performer in Westerns

Mentioning Montgomery Clift brings to mind his exceptional performance alongside John Wayne in the 1948 film Red River. Clift's portrayal was outstanding, and although his career in Westerns may not have reached its full potential due to the era, his talent shone through in every role. In Red River, Clift and Wayne's intense on-screen chemistry is a testament to Clift's skill, even if his career had to navigate challenges beyond the Western genre.

Clift's career saw him excel in various roles, but his brush with Westerns remains a lasting contribution. His ability to bring depth and complexity to his characters, even in the action-packed settings of the Western genre, is a testament to his acting prowess. While his work in Westerns may not have garnered him the same level of recognition as his work in other genres, the influence of his performance in Red River is undeniable. His impact on Western cinema and beyond validates the importance of recognizing actors who made critical contributions to the genre.

Conclusion: The Legacy of Underrated Western Stars

These three actors—Lee Van Cleef, Harry Carey Jr., and Montgomery Clift—each brought a unique flavor to the Western genre. Despite their talent and extensive careers, they remain underappreciated when compared to more iconic figures in the genre. As we continue to explore and analyze the rich tapestry of Western cinema, it is essential to give these unsung heroes their due recognition. Their contributions not only added to the genre's historical significance but also paved the way for future generations of actors and filmmakers.