The Unanswered Question: Why Didn’t Palpatine Win Against Rey?

The climax of the The Rise of Skywalker raised a myriad of questions, but one in particular has sparked intense debate: why didn't Palpatine manage to win against Rey? This article delves into the intricate details and theories behind this pivotal battle, while also examining the role of Star Wars storytelling and the narrative choices that led to this outcome.

Debunking the Myths: Why Rey Won

After Anakin’s failure to become the Chosen One, the Force decided not to make the same mistake twice. Rey was granted the power and the guidance of the Jedi to defeat Palpatine. This outcome was in line with the prophecy that stated the redeemed Darth Vader would have a daughter who would stand against the Dark Side. Rey’s triumph over Palpatine was not just a display of sheer power, but also a testament to the legacy of her father, Anakin Skywalker.

Understanding Palpatine's Limitations

Palpatine, despite his ambition and the power of the Lightning of the Sith, is ultimately a flawed character. One of his greatest weaknesses is his inability to win, a principle deeply rooted in the natural order of the Force. When Rey deflects his Force Lightning back at him, it’s not just a matter of skill, but a reflection of the universe's refusal to let Palpatine prevail. This is a irony that resonates throughout the Rogue One: A Star Wars Story, The Force Awakens, and The Last Jedi.

Comparing Rey and Palpatine

Rey’s mastery of the Force is evident in the battle on the final stretch of the Death Star. She is not just a trained Jedi but someone who understands the underlying principles of the Force. Her ability to deflect Force Lightning back at Palpatine is a testament to her strength and the wisdom she has gained from the Jedi Order. In contrast, Palpatine’s knowledge of the Force was largely theoretical and boosted by his Sith training, making him more of a theoretical practitioner than a practical one.

Is Rey a Mary Sue?

Some critics have questioned whether Rey is a Mary Sue, someone who seems to have an excessive amount of idealized or unrealistic quality. However, this argument overlooks the complexity of her character. Rey’s strength is rooted in her human experiences and her ability to harness the Force. Her connection to the Force is a result of her unique background and the guidance of the Jedi, which makes her a more compelling and believable character than a mere creation of fan fiction.

Conclusion: The Power of Storytelling and Legacy

The narrative choices made in the sequel trilogy, while widely debated, contribute to the overall arc of the Star Wars saga. Rey's victory is not just a matter of plot but a symbol of the enduring legacy of the original trilogy. Palpatine’s loss in the final showdown is a consequence of his own hubris and the immutable principles of the Force. This outcome also serves as a reminder that every hero has a role to play in the greater tapestry of the galaxy.

Key Takeaways

Rey’s Legacy: As the daughter of Anakin Skywalker, Rey represents the culmination of the Force's prophesied destiny. Palpatine’s Limitations: His inability to win in the final battle is a reflection of the Force's balance and the natural order. Character vs. Plot: Rey’s success is a blend of character development and plot-driven narrative choices.

Further Reading

For a deeper dive into the world of Star Wars, explore these resources:

The Rise of Skywalker Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (9-episode series) Rey Palpatine