The Ultimate Choice: Brienne's Preference Between Tormund and Jamie

As the conflict between Tormund Giantsbane and Jamie Lannister intensifies, the question arises: would Brienne of Tarth choose either one to be with her in battle? Most would assume that she would pick Jamie. After all, Jamie is the one who protected her from harsh circumstances and fought for her. Yet, there is much more to Brienne's character that makes her choices slightly more complex. In this article, we explore the reasoning behind her potential choice and delve deeper into her character dynamics in the context of A Song of Ice and Fire.

Understanding Brienne's Character

Brienne of Tarth, the Lady Without One, is known for her unyielding sense of chivalry and her protective nature. She does not shy away from physical confrontations and is respected for her strength and courage. However, her demeanor often belies a more nuanced and deeply emotional side. Throughout her journey, she has encountered various characters who each bring a distinct dynamic to her story.

Why Choose Jamie?

It would seem evident that Brienne might choose Jamie Lannister, especially given his past actions. In A Clash of Kings, Jamie protected Brienne from being forcibly married off and made the ultimate sacrifice by severing his hand to save her from a beast. His protection and selflessness are undeniably admirable traits. Furthermore, their shared moments, such as the incident with the bear and the intimacy in the bath, suggest a level of trust and respect that goes beyond mere proximity. Jamie's willingness to share his most precious possession, the Valyrian steel sword, with Brienne underscores his belief in her worth and trust in her.

Why Choose Tormund?

However, it is essential to consider the other side of the argument. Tormund Giantsbane, the wild man from the north, might seem like an unlikely choice at first glance. His rough demeanor and semi-barbaric behavior could be off-putting, but the wildness in Tormund could also be seen as a refreshing change. He is a character known for his outlandish and often disruptive behavior, which could be attractive to someone like Brienne who seeks a change from her usual environment. His righteous anger and sense of wild freedom might resonate with Brienne, who has often been portrayed as somewhat rigid in her pursuit of justice and chivalry. Additionally, Tormund's open and non-conformist nature might provide a new perspective for Brienne, allowing her to explore a different side of herself.

The Unseen Side of Brienne

Beyond her chivalrous exterior, Brienne of Tarth has a softer side that is rarely seen. Her relationship with Jaime Lannister is complex because of the bond they share, but it is also tainted by expectations and societal pressures. In contrast, Tormund's journey as a wild man might offer her a release from these confines. His unpredictability and willingness to express himself freely could be the key to unlocking a more liberated version of her character. This suggests that Brienne might choose Tormund because of the potential for personal growth and self-discovery that such a relationship could offer.

The Future and Unread Books

It is worth noting that this analysis is based solely on the show, and the books by George R.R. Martin may offer additional insights into Brienne's character and motivations. Until then, it remains an open question, leaving fans and readers to ponder and speculate over the many possibilities. Whether she chooses Tormund or Jamie, it is clear that each choice would anchor her journey with a distinct personality and perspective, ultimately enriching the narrative of A Song of Ice and Fire.