The Theories and Debates Surrounding Anakin Skywalker's Mother, Shmi

Ever since the release of the Star Wars franchise, there have been countless debates and theories surrounding the intricacies of the story. One of the more intriguing questions revolves around Anakin Skywalker's own mother, Shmi Skywalker. Many have pondered over the events leading up to her untimely demise and the impact of her choice to let Anakin go to improve his life. This article delves into these theories and explores the role of Qui-Gon Jinn, as well as other key figures in Shmi's story.

Qui-Gon Jinn and Shmi Skywalker

One of the theories suggests that Shmi Skywalker wouldn't have had to face the tragic end if it wasn't for Qui-Gon Jinn's intervention. According to this viewpoint, Shmi would have remained safe under the care of Senator Palpatine—then known as Chancellorvals—and would have had the chance to live a life free from danger. However, let's examine the reality of the situation.

Nearly everyone agrees that Shmi Skywalker died at the hands of Tusken raiders, as evidenced by recent movies and canonical sources. The Tusken raiders, a nomadic group native to Tatooine, were notorious for their savagery and relentless attacks on settlers. This act of violence led to Shmi's tragic demise. It is important to note that the prequels, despite their controversies, offer a historical account of the events. In "Attack of the Clones," Senator Palpatine does indeed have Shmi under his surveillance, but the interception of Dooku's message ultimately leads to her death.

The Role of Cletus Lars and Watto

Another theory posits that Cletus Lars, a Senator, saved Shmi by buying her from Watto, the slave dealer who owned her. This notion is often referenced when discussing the impact of external interventions. However, the exact sequence of events is still a matter of debate. It is likely that Cletus Lars and Watto were involved in the events, but whether Lars saved Shmi or simply purchased her remains unclear. The canonical evidence points to the fact that Shmi was eventually killed by the Tusken raiders, regardless of any prior transactions.

Impact on Anakin's Journey

Much of the discussion revolves around how Shmi's death would have affected Anakin's journey. Critics argue that had Shmi lived on, Anakin might not have embarked on his path towards the Jedi Order. In fact, it is often suggested that Shmi's choice to let Anakin go—to seize his chance for a better life—could have completely altered the course of events. In this scenario, Anakin wouldn't have become a Jedi Knight, and the Dark Side of the Force may never have taken root in his life.

Without being a slave or burden, it is speculated that Shmi and Anakin could have led a peaceful life on Naboo or even on the Galactic Capital of Coruscant. This idea stems from the belief that if both had the opportunity to leave Tatooine, they might have chosen to live more fulfilling and safer lives away from the dangers of slavery and conflict.

The Existence of the Prequels and Controversies

However, revisiting the prequels and their implications leads to yet another layer of debate. Some enthusiasts are so attached to the original trilogy that they dismiss the entire prequels, viewing them as a mere figment of their imagination. They argue that the prequels, along with the controversial characters like Anakin, Jar Jar Binks, and the sequels, are detrimental to the Star Wars saga. Critics point to the unrealistic portrayal of Jango Fett and Boba Fett, as well as the much-maligned appearance of Darth Vader as a child in the Return of the Jedi.

This perspective often aligns with the idea of Doublethink, a term borrowed from George Orwell's Nineteen Eighty-Four. This mental exercise involves erasing certain memories and refusing to acknowledge the existence of certain characters and events. It is seen as a way to maintain a purer version of the Star Wars universe, free from the controversies surrounding the prequels and sequels.

Alternatively, some individuals choose to accept the prequels for what they are, seeing them as an alternate timeline that hasn't yet been written into the Star Wars storyline. This view acknowledges the novel elements introduced in the prequels while maintaining an open mind about their place in the overall narrative.

Conclusion

Whether one believes in the prequels or not, the theories and debates surrounding Anakin Skywalker's mother, Shmi, remain a fascinating aspect of the Star Wars universe. The events of her life and death continue to inspire conjecture and discussion, as fans try to understand the full impact of these events on the lives of the Jedi and the Sith. For those who are trying to navigate the complex web of Star Wars, embracing Doublethink or accepting the full saga as a cohesive whole can be a challenge but also a source of endless fascination.