The Speculation Around Ashara Dayne: Meera Reed's Mother

The theory that Ashara Dayne is the mother of Meera Reed is a popular speculation among fans of Game of Thrones. While the intrigue of such a connection is undeniable, there are several compelling reasons to believe this theory is largely speculative and may not hold up under a close examination of the narrative and timeline.

Ashara Dayne, a noblewoman from Dorne known for her beauty and tragic fate, and Meera Reed, a skilled hunter and warrior hailing from House Reed from the Neck, share a mysterious connection primarily based on circumstantial evidence. This includes their timelines and the mysterious nature of Meera's parentage. Despite the appeal of linking these two characters, the evidence presented within the narrative and the works of George R.R. Martin himself provides compelling reasons to question the validity of this theory.

Examination of Ashara Dayne and Howland Reed

One of the primary arguments against the Ashara-Howland theory is the characterization of Howland Reed. Howland is not presented as a particularly attractive or suitable suitor within the narrative. His romantic relationships and interests are more centered around practical and political concerns, rather than the romantic interests of a noblewoman from Dorne.

In contrast, Ashara's romantic connections seem to center around Brandon Stark and Ned Stark. These characters are markedly different from Howland, who is often depicted as a more political and pragmatic figure. Furthermore, Ashara's relationship with Howland would seem unsatisfying and unfulfilling within the narrative, given her extensive romantic history and the drama surrounding it.

The theory also suggests that if Ashara were linked to Howland, she would have to have a child with him, leading to a revealing of Ashara's past. However, this theory does not feel compelling or well-executed. It feels like a missed opportunity for George R.R. Martin to explore other aspects of Howland's backstory and Dayne family history that would have provided more satisfying revelations.

The True Mother of Meera Reed

Further evidence against the Ashara-Howland theory comes from the character of Allyria Dayne, who is determined to be Ashara's daughter. Allyria is known for carrying a child fathered by Brandon Stark, which makes it more plausible that Ashara might have a connection to someone from the Stark line rather than the Reed line.

Additionally, there are several points within the narrative that suggest Ashara and Howland were not together during the time of Meera's birth. It is mentioned that during the war, Ashara would likely have been on Dragonstone, in King's Landing, or at Stark House (Starfall) while Howland was fighting in the war. This timeline discrepancy further supports the idea that Ashara and Howland did not have a significant connection.

The Relevance of Considerations

The characteristics of Meera and Jojen Reed also do not align with the Ashara-Howland theory. Both Meera and Jojen carry typical features for people from the Neck, and there is no clear evidence suggesting they are of Dayne heritage. The fact that they do not stand out in any noticeable way among the crannogmen, such as being taller or bigger, further weakens this theory.

Considering the narrative, it feels like a more compelling reveal could be achieved if Ashara were not Howland's wife. This would open the door for more intriguing storylines and character developments, both for Ashara and the Dayne family, and for Howland himself, who remains a mysterious and intriguing character throughout the series.

In conclusion, while the idea of Ashara being Meera's mother is an interesting and popular speculation, the details of the narrative and the established facts presented by George R.R. Martin suggest that this theory is less likely to be canon. Exploring the stories of other characters and their connections could offer a more satisfying reveal and a richer narrative experience.