The Shifting Alignments of Angels and Devils in Dungeons and Dragons

Alignment is a fundamental concept in Dungeons and Dragons (DnD), providing a framework for the behavior and motivations of both player characters and non-player characters (NPCs). However, it is important to understand that these guidelines are not set in stone. DnD's alignment system is designed to be flexible, allowing Dungeon Masters (DMs) and players to explore the complex motivations and moral ambiguities that can arise in a campaign.

The Core Foundations of Alignment in 5e

As stated by the official rules, alignment is one of the core foundations of the DnD system. But these rules are intended to be a starting point, not a strict set of laws. The system provides a set of basic guidelines but encourages DMs and players to adapt and expand upon them. The flexibility of the alignment system allows for creativity and depth in character development.

Some players and DMs are meticulous about adhering to the rules as written (RAW), while others view the alignment system as a too restrictive framework. However, both approaches can lead to a misunderstanding of the true purpose of the 5th Edition's alignment system. Its primary role is to facilitate roleplay and provide a shorthand for understanding character behavior, rather than limiting it.

Blurring the Lines Between Guideline and Reality

Tweaking the alignment system to suit your campaign can create a richer and more immersive experience. Many DMs and players are beginning to treat supernatural beings, such as angels and devils, as complex individuals who can make their own choices. Instead of viewing their alignment as unchangeable, they see it as a dynamic aspect of their character's development.

Lawful Evil: Beyond Nazi-like Facets

When an angel aligns with lawful evil, it does not mean they are bound to behave as Nazis. Instead, lawful evil can represent a complex moral code that prioritizes order and hierarchy at the expense of individual freedoms. For example, a lawful evil angel might be drawn to become chaotic evil (chaos over lawful) to escape the rigid control and structure of an oppressive system that seeks to dominate all existence.

Devils and Their Possible Alignments

A devil, typically aligned with lawful evil, might choose to become chaotic evil not because it inherently exists to cause destruction, but due to dissatisfaction with the status quo. A devil might tire of the hierarchical and autocratic nature of its true form, refusing to be part of an evil empire that seeks to control and oppress all. Instead, it might seek a more unpredictable and free-open way of being evil.

It's also crucial to recognize that within the vast array of supernatural beings, not all fall into rigid categories. Some devils may have diverse alignments, from neutral to even good, though such an alignment shift would likely be temporary, as the inherent nature of devils in DnD includes a bias towards chaotic evil. However, the possibility of change adds depth and nuance to the world of DnD.

Conclusion: Embracing Flexibility

The key to a compelling DnD campaign lies in the ability to adapt and experiment with the alignment system. By recognizing it as a flexible tool rather than a strict constraint, DMs and players can create richer, more engaging stories and characters. Whether an angel chooses lawful evil or a devil seeks a more chaotic path, these shifts can provide exciting character development and dynamic interactions within the campaign.

In the end, the shifting alignment of supernatural beings is a testament to the complex and multifaceted nature of moral decision-making in a fantasy world. It is a rich source of narrative opportunities, where the player can explore the depths of their characters' motivations and the intricate balance of good and evil. The true spirit of DnD is found in the continuous exploration of these possibilities.