The Role of the Kingsguard in A Song of Ice and Fire: An Analysis

In George R.R. Martin's epic fantasy series, A Song of Ice and Fire, the decision to send only three members of the Kingsguard to accompany King Robert Baratheon on his visit to Winterfell is a multifaceted one, reflecting both practical considerations and political maneuvers. This decision is intricately tied to the duties, logistics, and the complex political landscape of the Seven Kingdoms.

A Multifaceted Decision: The Role of the Kingsguard

The Kingsguard, sworn to protect the king, also has critical responsibilities at the royal court in King's Landing. Sending an entire retinue to Winterfell would leave the court vulnerable and underprotected. This strategic decision is further complicated by the political implications of Robert's visit to Winterfell. The journey to Winterfell is a significant political move to solidify alliances with the Starks and show trust towards House Stark.

Practical Considerations

The journey to Winterfell is long and treacherous. A smaller retinue is easier to manage and can travel more swiftly, ensuring the safety of King Robert and the companions. Additionally, Robert may have preferred a smaller group to avoid drawing undue attention. The three members chosen—Ser Jaime Lannister, Ser Barristan Selmy, and Ser Meryn Trant—reflect a mix of loyalty and political calculation. Ser Barristan Selmy, as Lord Commander of the Kingsguard and the top general of the Seven Kingdoms, remained at King's Landing to manage the garrison. This leaves the three most loyal members to Robert traveling to Winterfell, ensuring both protection and diplomacy.

Political Stratagem and Loyalty

Interestingly, the three chosen for the journey are the most loyal to Cersei, suggesting a potential influence from Cersei herself. This decision can be seen as a political maneuver to maintain her influence over the Kingsguard and to protect her interests. Similarly, the selection of these three members might have been influenced by the necessity to maintain the loyalty of the Lannister loyalists within the Kingsguard.

Character Development and Limitations

It's also worth noting that this decision might reflect the limited development of some characters in the series. For instance, the name of the predecessor who died nine years ago and allowed Arys Oakheart to ascend to the Kingsguard is never revealed. This absence of information could have been due to the ongoing development of the storyline and character backgrounds.

Conclusion

The decision to send only three members of the Kingsguard to Winterfell for King Robert Baratheon is a nuanced choice motivated by a blend of practicality, politics, and the strategic needs of the Seven Kingdoms. This decision, made by George R.R. Martin, underscores the complex interplay of loyalty, trust, and political maneuvering in the world of A Song of Ice and Fire.