The Role of Narrators in TV Shows: A Closer Look at NCIS and 48 Hours - NCIS

Are Narrators Essential for All TV Shows?

When it comes to TV shows, especially crime procedurals, the question of whether a narrator is necessary often arises. While some shows, such as Criminal Minds, utilize narrators to provide additional background or context, others, including NCIS and the newest version of 48 Hours - NCIS, do not have a narrator at all. This article delves into the reasons why some shows do not need a narrator while others benefit from this element.

Why NCIS Does Not Need a Narrator

NCIS, as one of the most popular crime procedurals, has built a reputation for its compelling storytelling and tight plot lines without the aid of a narrator. The show is known for its high tension and intricate narratives, which are delivered through its characters' actions and interactions. The narrator, in this case, could feel like an unnecessary middleman, detracting from the viewer's experience.

For those who mistakenly thought NCIS had a narrator, a moment of frustration may have been experienced when the name of the narrator quickly flashed during the episode's opening credits. However, the show's creators made a conscious decision to avoid this element. As one viewer noted, 'my cat accidentally activated the SAP feature, but it quickly turned off,' highlighting the accidental activation of this feature, which is typically used for the visually impaired.

The New '48 Hours - NCIS' with a Narrator

In contrast to the original NCIS, the newer show titled 48 Hours - NCIS is different. This co-production by USA Network and NCIS offers true stories narrated by Rocky Carroll, a well-known figure within the NCIS community. This format allows viewers to gain insight directly from the source, enhancing the authenticity of the show. The narrated stories provide additional context and details that might otherwise be lost in the original show's structure.

Does Criminal Minds Need a Narrator?

While Criminal Minds does not have a regular narrator, the show does use voice-overs for various characters reading quotes. These voice-overs are not considered narration in the traditional sense, as they are often used to offer psychological insights or observations related to the ongoing story. For example, voice-overs might introduce segments or provide commentary on the behavior of the unsub (unidentified subject) or the profilers. These quotes are part of the show's storytelling process rather than providing narrative explanations.

Conclusion: The Impact of Narrators on Viewer Experience

The presence or absence of a narrator in TV shows can significantly influence the viewing experience. NCIS relies on its compelling storyline and characters to engage its audience, while 48 Hours - NCIS uses narration for authenticity and to provide additional context. Meanwhile, Criminal Minds employs voice-overs to offer psychological insights, making it an essential part of the show's narrative structure.

Ultimately, the inclusion of a narrator depends on the show's format and the specific narrative style it employs. Whether a narrator is necessary or not is a subjective decision that varies from show to show, influenced by the show's tone, storytelling, and target audience.

Keywords: TV show narrators, NCIS, 48 Hours - NCIS