Why Was NBC Unimpressed with the Original Star Trek Pilot?

The early attempts to bring Star Trek to life were fraught with challenges. Understanding the reasons behind NBC's rejection of the original pilot can provide insight into the creative journey of Star Trek.

Herb Solow and Robert Justman's Perspective

According to Herb Solow and Robert Justman, NBC opted to accept the Star Trek pilot based on several factors. Initially, NBC was concerned about Desi-Lu Productions' capability to produce a high-quality show that could match the standards of Star Trek. NBC placed a bar for the hardest possible episode to complete, and once the first pilot, titled The Cage, was reviewed, it impressed with its quality. This recognition led NBC to commission a second pilot.

Content of the Original Pilot

The original pilot of Star Trek faced criticism from NBC for several reasons. It was perceived as too cerebral, lacked sufficient action, and featured a female first officer, a concept that was uncommon at the time. The rejection highlights the cultural and gender norms of the late 1960s. The captain, Christopher Pike, along with Spock, the Orions, and the slave girl belly dancer, all contributed to the show's unique and intriguing storyline.

Specific Rejections and Changes

NBC had several specific issues with the original pilot. One of the concerns was the appearance of Mr. Spock, who was described as too devilish looking. NBC asked Leonard Nimoy to change the design of Spock by removing the ears and softening his features. Additionally, the female first officer, played by Majel Barrett, who was the girlfriend of creator Gene Roddenberry, was removed. Barretrieved this information from an interview with Roddenberry and NBC executives.

Actor Challenges

Jeffrey Hunter, who played Captain Pike, did not enjoy the role after playing Jesus in "King of Kings." His wife felt it was undignified for him to appear in a science fiction series. This led to his departure from the project, and William Shatner took over the role of Captain Kirk. The female second-in-command was removed by marrying her to Spock.

NBC's Final Verdict and Head of Production

NBC eventually concluded that the pilot was "too cerebral" and did not believe it would appeal to a mass audience. However, Lucille Ball, who was a significant head of production at Desi-Lu, believed in the show and saw its potential. Her support meant the pilot still found a way to air, paving the way for the future success of Star Trek.

Conclusion

The journey of bringing Star Trek to the airwaves was marked by several hurdles, but the rejection of the original pilot played a crucial role in shaping the show we know today. The experience of NBC offered valuable lessons and adjustments that transformed the series, leading to its enduring legacy.