The Psychological Impact of the Capitol Insurrection: Live TV vs. News Reports

The events of January 6, 2021, at the United States Capitol have had a significant psychological impact on those who witnessed them. This article explores the differences between those who watched the Capitol insurrection happening live and those who watched edited and re-reported versions later, and delves into the ongoing emotional trauma.

Live vs. Post-EVENT Coverage

The distinction between viewing the Capitol insurrection live and watching edited and re-reported versions later is clear. The experience of observing the events unfold in real time can be much more impactful than watching a sanitized, reinterpreted version of the same events.

Those who watched the insurrection live on television may have experienced a more immediate and visceral reaction, feeling a sense of despair and confusion. Alternatively, those who saw the events afterwards through edited and rereported news broadcasts may have felt less of an emotional impact because the message was often distorted or exaggerated.

The question remains: do those who watched the insurrection on live TV feel more of a psychological impact than those who only watched it on news broadcasts afterward? Given the immediacy and rawness of live coverage, the answer is often yes. Live coverage allows viewers to absorb the events as they happen, making the impact more profound.

Inside the Jails and Solitary Confinement

The conditions inside the jails and solitary confinement facilities for individuals held after the insurrection are particularly disturbing. Reports suggest that 750 people were held in solitary confinement, beaten, and denied necessary medical and dental care. Moreover, the vast majority of those held had no charges filed against them and were held for almost a year with no indication of an insurrection or involvement with weapons.

This situation, both unjust and inhumane, highlights the serious psychological impact that has been inflicted on individuals as a result of the insurrection. The withholding of medical treatment, the denial of basic care, and prolonged detention without cause can all contribute to deep psychological trauma.

The Nature of the Protest

Many who watched the Capitol insurrection on live TV saw a protest that was largely peaceful. While the events unfolded, the lack of violence, arson, and property damage distinguished it from the flaming and destructive protests by groups like Antifa and Black Lives Matter (BLM) that took place in US cities the year before.

Antifa and BLM protests often involved arson, arson of buildings and cars, injuries and deaths, and billions in property damage and looting. In contrast, the Capitol insurrection was mostly peaceful. This has led some to question the use of the term "insurrection" to describe the events.

Propaganda and Deception

The psychological impact of the Capitol insurrection was further amplified by the deceptive news media. These outlets propagated the term "insurrection" to describe a relatively peaceful protest. This contrast with their previous reluctance to use the same term to characterize the Antifa and BLM protests highlights a clear case of propaganda and misinformation.

The insurrection on live TV had a lasting impact for many, with feelings of anger and disgust persisting for months after the event. For some, such as myself, the psychological impact persisted even ten months later.

Viewing the FBI's released videos showed a far clearer picture of the struggle and mob mentality that was out of control. Weeks before the event, I became aware of the buildup, thanks to social media.

The Ongoing Denial and Twisting of Narrative

The denial and twisting of the narrative surrounding the Capitol insurrection are as troubling as the events themselves. Those on the right have been keen to blame others, such as Democrats, for the insurrection. Initially, they pointed fingers at Antifa and BLM. Later, they tried to blame the FBI. However, the FBI found no evidence of involvement other than Trump's followers.

The shifting narratives from "it was no big deal" to a lack of seriousness in addressing the issue have added to the psychological impact. The use of "what aboutism" or trying to compare the riots for civil rights to the attempt to overturn the election is an attempt to divert attention from the real issue.

It is important to remember that the looters and arsonists were typically rounded up and punished. Calling for justice and recognizing the seriousness of the event is crucial for healing and moving forward. Playground whining or playing down the issue serves no one.

Understanding the psychological impact of the Capitol insurrection is crucial. Live TV coverage can have a profound effect on individuals, and the ongoing denial and twisting of the narrative can exacerbate these effects. It is essential to address these issues openly and with empathy for all those affected.