The Oath of the Night's Watch and Samwell Tarly's Journey

The Night's Watch, a formidable and solemn order rooted deeply in the history of Westeros, requires its members to adhere to a strict code of conduct. One pivotal figure in this saga is Samwell Tarly, who at times appears to challenge this sacred oath. This article delves into the question of whether Samwell Tarly truly broke his vows to the Night's Watch, analyzing the show, the books, and the underlying themes.

Analysis in the Television Series

Samwell Tarly began his tenure as a member of the Night's Watch, a position that required him to remain aloof from the politics and affairs of the realm and to practice celibacy. However, throughout the series, his obligations to Jon Snow and later his personal life with Gilly and their child resulted in a significant departure from these vows. In the show, Sam's actions are clear violations of his oaths, as he actively participates in the affairs of the realm and forms a familial bond, which are strictly prohibited for members of the Night's Watch.

Analysis in the Books

In the novels, the situation is more nuanced. While Sam does not explicitly break his oaths to the same extent as in the series, his loyalty to the Night's Watch remains a recurring theme. His relationships and choices, particularly his interactions with Gilly and their son, test his commitment to the vows he took. The crucial question here is whether Sam's personal connections and moral choices overshadow his strict adherence to his Night's Watch vows.

Post-Game of Thrones

It is worth noting that the Night's Watch continues to exist post-Game of Thrones. Jon Snow, upon discovering the truth about his parentage, was sent north to join the Night's Watch. The Night's Watch remains a powerful force, serving as a deterrent against the Wildlings and the impending threat of the Night King. Samwell Tarly's actions, particularly his departure for the Citadel, were technically aimed at becoming a Maester and returning to his duty at Castle Black. His absence from the Night's Watch, however, does not absolve him of his initial vows.

Legality and Status

Samwell Tarly was officially given leave to train to become a Maester for the Night’s Watch. According to the rules, he was required to return to Castle Black after completing his training. His failure to do so resulted in him becoming a deserter. However, the new king pardoned him, which further complicates his status. It is debated whether Sam was ever officially released from his Night’s Watch vows or whether he was simply pardoned for his actions.

Respective Opinions and Debates

The question of whether Samwell Tarly broke his vows is not a simple one. Opinions vary widely among fans and scholars alike. Some believe that he willingly chose to break his vows, while others argue that his actions, though controversial, were aimed at fulfilling his duty to the realm and the Night's Watch. The interference of the plot, with characters like Grand Maester Targaryen taking on a mentor role, also adds complexity to the question. Sam’s ultimate goal was to ensure the survival of the Night's Watch and its mission, even as he made personal sacrifices.

Conclusion

The question of whether Samwell Tarly broke his oath to the Night's Watch is a multifaceted one, rooted in both the show and the books. While his actions in the show clearly violate his vows, the books present a more nuanced picture. Ultimately, the decision to interpret Sam's actions as breaking his oaths or as fulfilling his broader duty to the realm and the Night's Watch is up to the individual reader. Regardless of the interpretation, Sam's journey is a compelling examination of the tensions between personal ethics and the solemn commitment to a sacred cause.