The Northerners in Game of Thrones: Cautious or Racist?

The characters in the Game of Thrones series, specifically the Northerners, have often been portrayed as reserved and wary. Many viewers and critics have questioned whether their hesitation stems from a racist attitude or simple caution. In this article, we will explore the nuances of the Northerners' behaviors and attitudes, drawing upon both the narrative and the historical context of the series.

Northerners and Independence

The Northerners, particularly the Starks, have always valued their autonomy and independence. They have often rejected southern rulers who sought to exert control over the North. The Stark family, under the leadership of Eddard Stark, believed in governing their own realm without interference from the south. This sense of self-sufficiency is reflected in Jon Snow's upbringing as well. Despite the complexities of his heritage, Jon embraces the values of the North, including their need for caution when dealing with outsiders.

Daenerys Targaryen's Arrivals

Daenerys Targaryen, a foreign queen, arrives with an army composed of dragons, Dothraki, and Unsullied. Her forceful and somewhat invasive nature did not sit well with the Northerners. Her backing of Robin Stark's claim to the Iron Throne and subsequent actions, including imprisoning their king, Jon, further soured their opinion. However, the Northerners were not inherently racist or unfriendly to outsiders. Instead, they were cautious due to their historical experiences with southern rulers and conquerors.

Historical Context of the North

Historically, the North has faced significant challenges from southern powers. The Knights of the Storm and the Targaryens, for example, brought drastic changes to the region. The Northerners have a long history of conflict and struggle against both the Bolton and Lannister families. Their caution arise from memories of betrayals and conquests from the south. This historical trauma has made them wary of any outsider attempting to establish dominion over them.

Interactions and Alliances

Despite their initial suspicion, the Northerners were not entirely close-minded. They have collaborated with various southern factions in the past, such as the Riverlords, the Vale, and the Stormlands. Jon even accepts the title of Winter King, a position granted by the Vale. The critical point is that these alliances have been pragmatic and mutually beneficial, not rooted in any inherent racism. The North has formed partnerships with other powers when it suited their interests and goals.

Conclusion: Caution Over Racism

In conclusion, the Northerners in Game of Thrones appear cautious rather than racist. Their hesitations are based on a history of conflicts with southern powers and a deep-seated desire for independence. It would be more accurate to attribute their behavior to a cautious and pragmatic approach to dealing with outsiders, rather than an inherent racist attitude. The story shows the Northerners as resilient and strategic, recognizing the importance of self-governance and the need to make alliances when necessary.

The narrative of Game of Thrones highlights these complex attitudes, offering a rich tapestry of human interactions and political maneuvering. Understanding the motivations of the Northerners enriches our interpretation of the series and provides a nuanced perspective on the characters and their interactions.