The Longevity of ‘The Shining’: A Hidden Gem in Kubrick's Filmography

Like most Kubrick movies, The Shining is challenging to absorb on a first watch. This film, and many others by Kubrick, such as Full Metal Jacket, 2001: Space Odyssey, A Clockwork Orange, Barry Lyndon, and Doctor Strangelove, require a detailed exploration and repeated viewings. Stanley Kubrick, unlike many filmmakers, held a singular vision, operating independently from studio demands and market forces. His unique and idiosyncratic style has led to the enduring success of films like The Shining.

Challenges and Resistance

When The Shining was first released in theaters, it faced a mixed reception from audiences and critics. Two factors in particular made the film difficult to interpret on its initial release. Firstly, the dialogue was described as being oddly unnatural. It fell into the “uncanny valley” of being not quite normal, yet not completely artificial. This is best exemplified by Barry Dennen’s performance as Bill Watson, which was hilariously stilted.

Secondly, Jack Nicholson’s performance was widely criticized for being over-the-top and overly dramatic. Critics and audiences alike thought he was “overacting,” but this was precisely what Kubrick sought. The film, far from being a solemn horror, contains numerous comedic moments, all stemming from Nicholson’s genius line delivery.

Controversial Characters

The Shining#39;s lesser-known character, Wendy, faced criticism for her portrayal. Wendy was deemed even by Stephen King a simple housewife with no agency, yet Kubrick succeeded in getting the performance he wanted. Wendy does not become a girl boss but rather finds strength in protecting her children from a homicidal threat. Her physical appearance and demeanor also threw off audiences and critics, as she starkly contrasts with typical Hollywood starlets.

We also see the confusion surrounding the character of Scatman Crothers’s, who in the film travels from Florida to the Overlook Hotel and is immediately killed by Jack. Unlike in the book, in which Dick Halloran saves Wendy and Danny from Jack, this cinematic tangent was counterintuitive and contrary to narrative convention, leading to disappointment and confusion among audiences and critics.

In-depth Symbolism and Home Video

Another aspect that troubled audiences was the film's rich symbolism. When initially released, the complexity of these symbols was hard to decipher. It was not until the advent of home video that people were given the time and space to explore and interpret the film's complexities. This is where The Shining's true depth lies, and it is only through repeated viewings and thoughtful analysis that its true brilliance becomes apparent.

The Legacy of Kubrick

Stanley Kubrick was a film auteur who left an indelible mark on cinema, and The Shining is a testament to his unique vision. Despite initial resistance, the film has grown in popularity and appreciation over the years. Fans and critics alike have revisited The Shining numerous times, uncovering new layers of meaning and enjoying the film's complexity and nuance.

The Final Word

The enduring success of The Shining is a testament to the enduring power and influence of Kubrick's filmmaking. The film's challenging debut is now seen as a part of its charm, and it continues to captivate audiences and inspire new generations of filmmakers and horror enthusiasts.