The Journey Behind James Caan's Cast as Sonny Corleone: Behind the Lens of 'The Godfather'

The casting of James Caan as Sonny Corleone in The Godfather ranks as one of the most pivotal moments in cinema history. However, it was not a straightforward process. The story of how Caan eventually secured the role and the unexpected turn of events during the casting process provide fascinating insights into the making of this legendary film.

Robert DeNiro's Audition and the Sonny Role

It's often said that the road to becoming a star is paved with near misses and alternative outcomes. Robert DeNiro, a rising star at the time, auditioned for the role of Sonny Corleone. Among other talented actors, DeNiro showed his potential, but he was ultimately passed over for the role. What made the decision even more interesting is that DeNiro was chosen for the towering, muscular Michael Corleone instead. The choice seems to hint at the height and physique that DeNiro brought to the role, which is an essential aspect of the character.

The Quicksand of Casting: Keeping the Production_smooth

Director Francis Ford Coppola, who was entrusted with the monumental task of casting for what would become one of the most iconic films ever made, faced a chaotic process. Robert Evans, who oversaw the casting, insisted on holding numerous auditions for the different roles. This decision was made to ensure that the right actors were selected for each part. Coppola, however, was frustrated. The constant casting requests were an unwelcome break in his concentration on the film's pre-production and its actual filming. The tension between the two men was palpable as each had different visions for the film.

Caan's Character Fit and the Michael Role

James Caan, known for his powerful on-screen presence, was eventually cast as Michael Corleone, the eldest Corleone son. This casting decision was made on the advice of Robert Evans, who wisely recognized that Caan's character fit the role perfectly. His casting as Michael was a significant turning point in the project, as he brought a depth and gravitas to the character that was essential for the film's success.

Robert Evans and His Challenging Relationships

Robert Evans, a powerful figure in Hollywood, had a contentious relationship with many key figures involved with the film. He was known for his disdain towards Marlon Brando's unconventional behavior, and he nicknamed Al Pacino a 'midget,' which only added to their estrangement. Evans' dissatisfaction with Coppola was also a source of friction, contributing to the already tense atmosphere on set.

The Corleones and Their Faith: Fact vs. Fiction

The real-life family dynamics between the actors portraying the Corleone brothers were equally interesting. James Caan, who took on the role of Sonny, and Abe Vigoda, who played his henchman Tessio, were both of Jewish descent but played Catholic characters in the film. This intriguing crossover adds an additional layer to the film's rich tapestry of characters. Similarly, Alex Rocco, known for his stereotypical portrayal of Moe Green, a Jewish character in the movie, was actually a Catholic in real life. These juxtapositions between character and reality add a unique flavor to the portrayal of this iconic family in the film.

Conclusion: The Legacy of 'The Godfather'

From the initial auditions to the casting of James Caan and the subsequent challenges faced by Francis Ford Coppola, 'The Godfather' remains a testament to the intricate process of bringing a timeless story to life. The journey behind Caan's casting as Sonny Corleone not only highlights the importance of the role but also underscores the human aspects of filmmaking.

Key Takeaways

James Caan's casting as Sonny Corleone marked a significant moment in the making of 'The Godfather'. Robert DeNiro auditioned for the same role but was eventually cast as Michael Corleone. Robert Evans' insistence on multiple auditions disrupted the smooth production process. The Corleone brothers in the film, despite being played by Italians, were Jewish in reality.