Did Grindelwald Feel Jealous of Newt and Dumbledore?

There is no denying that Gellert Grindelwald exhibited feelings of envy towards both Newt Scamander and Albus Dumbledore. However, the nature of that envy varies significantly between the two characters, reflecting the complex dynamics within the wizarding world.

Jealousy of Newt Scamander

While Grindelwald’s feelings towards Newt are not as explicitly discussed in the canon material, they can be inferred through his desire for power and his ambition to reshape the wizarding world. Newt, a gifted magizoologist, is a beacon of diversity and coexistence, challenging Grindelwald’s more autocratic views. Grindelwald’s disdain for those who oppose his vision could manifest as jealousy, particularly over Newt’s moral standing and the loyalty he inspires in others.

Jealousy of Albus Dumbledore

Grindelwald's jealousy towards Albus Dumbledore is more pronounced and deeply rooted in their shared past. As former friends with grand aspirations for the wizarding world, their paths diverged due to differing beliefs about power and control. Grindelwald’s envy is primarily fueled by Dumbledore’s moral authority and the fact that he ultimately chose to stand against Grindelwald. This rivalry is central to the narrative, particularly in 'Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald' and 'The Deathly Hallows' series.

A Deeper Analysis: The Dumbledore-Grindelwald Connection

The analogy drawn between Dumbledore and Grindelwald to the X-Men characters Professor X (Cyclops) and Magneto, respectively, offers a compelling perspective. Just as Professor X and Magneto share similar origins and views on the world, Dumbledore and Grindelwald once held similar ideals, reflecting Grindelwald's transformation into a dark figure.

Grindelwald and Dumbledore's shared history provides insight into the relationships between Professor X and Magneto. They were once close, with deep discussions that helped shape both their worldviews. This similarity in development mirrors the complexity of the Dumbledore-Grindelwald dynamic, highlighting how the same factors can influence different outcomes.

Newt as Beast

Newt Scamander, like Bishop/Beast, represents a form of genius in his field. Both characters fight for the rights of their kind and strive for coexistence with others. Newt’s career with the MACUSA and his later involvement in the fight against Grindelwald reflect a similar journey to Bishop/Beast, who battles for mutant rights and the acceptance of mutants and humans.

A Difference in Opinion, Not Jealousy

While Newt and Dumbledore are both admirable figures, the evidence suggests that Grindelwald's feelings towards them are not primarily driven by jealousy. Instead, his attitude is more characterized by a deep-seated disagreement. Grindelwald either wishes for his own magical prowess or wishes Newt and Dumbledore dead, indicating a lack of middle ground. This is similar to how Magneto views Bishop/Beast.

Just as Professor X understands and respects Magneto's goals, albeit not agreeing with them, Dumbledore and Grindelwald recognize and respect each other's perspectives. However, this mutual understanding necessitates that they stand against each other, for they know what the other is thinking and why. In this sense, their respect and understanding highlight a profound and unbreakable bond of honor and love.

In conclusion, Grindelwald's envy towards Newt and Dumbledore is more about differing views and ideals rather than personal jealousy. The parallels drawn between these characters from both worlds underscore the complexity of their relationships and the profound impact of their shared history on their fates.