The Impact of Training Sidious in the Jedi Order: A Comprehensive Analysis

The question of whether Darth Sidious, the primary antagonist of the Star Wars saga, would have achieved a different outcome if trained in the Jedi Order from childbirth is a fascinating one. This analysis delves into the potential outcomes, considering his adherence to the Sith Plan and the role of midichlorian count, among other factors.

Training in the Jedi Order: Theoretical Scenarios

If Darth Sidious were to have been raised within the Jedi Order from infancy, could he have ascended beyond the levels of his eventual Sith counterparts, such as Darth Tyranus (Dooku) and Mace Windu? Let's explore the possibilities.

Raw Force Power and Midichlorian Count

The midichlorian count is a key indicator of a Jedi's Force prowess. Darth Sidious is known to have had a significantly higher midichlorian count than Mace Windu, Yoda, and even Darth Tyranus (Dooku). According to estimates, Sidious's midichlorian count was around 20,000 higher than Mace Windu's, which places him in a league beyond the Jedi Order's most renowned members. This biological advantage would likely have endowed Sidious with powerful Force abilities, potentially allowing him to perform feats that even Mace Windu and Yoda could not achieve.

Sabre Fighting Proficiency

While midichlorian count is a significant factor, it is not the only variable in a Jedi's success. Sabre fighting proficiency is also crucial. According to the Star Wars canon, Darth Tyranus (Dooku) was one of the best sabre fighters, and he could have potentially challenged his master due to his skill level. However, if Sidious had been trained in the Jedi Order, he would have likely faced the same rigorous training as other Jedi. Additionally, since Sidious is known to have had a greater affinity for the Dark Side, it is possible that he could have surpassed Dooku in saber fighting, as Dooku would have been inclined to challenge a potential threat to his mastery.

Dark Side vs. Light Side

The Dark Side provides immense power, but it also fosters a deeper connection to the Force, allowing a Sith to stay at the forefront of their abilities. Sidious's adherence to the Sith Plan and his understanding of 1,000 years of Sith knowledge gave him an unparalleled edge. This knowledge, coupled with his higher midichlorian count, could have propelled him to surpass Dooku in both Force abilities and sabre fighting proficiency. However, in the light of the ability of Dark Side users like Darth Sidious to wield greater power, it is debatable whether he would have been better than Mace Windu.

Together as Masters

In the context of the Jedi Order, Sidious, Dooku, and Mace Windu would form an impressive trio of Jedi Masters. Sidious would certainly be the most powerful, while Dooku would remain one of the top sabre fighters. Windu, with his unique Vaapad form, would be an important member of the team. Together, they would be formidable in any confrontation.

Motivation and Dark Side Influence

Motivation is a critical factor in any discussion of exceptional achievement. Sidious's drive to control the universe may not have been as strong if he had been raised in the Jedi Order, as the Jedi philosophy often emphasizes peace and balance rather than domination. This could potentially limit his ambition and power compared to when he embraced the Dark Side. However, his natural affinity for the Sith and the immense power he could have gained through his midichlorian count would likely have driven him to excel in any setting, even within the Jedi Order.

Conclusion

In terms of raw Force ability, Darth Sidious would stand out among his peers, surpassing both Dooku and Mace Windu. His sabre fighting proficiency, while likely on par with Dooku, would be influenced by his enhanced combat skills and understanding gained from the Sith Plan. When contextualized within the Jedi Order, Sidious would form a powerful triumvirate alongside Dooku and Windu, but his eventual rise to Darth Sidious was as much a testament to his intrinsic Dark Side potential as it was to the advantages provided by the Jedi Order.