The Hobbit Movie Trilogy: My Favorites and Why They Stand Out

Introduction

The Hobbit film trilogy, directed by Peter Jackson, is a unique combination of triumphs and tribulations. While many viewers found the films hit a low level at times, I, for one, found that my favorite elements of the trilogy were somewhat frontloaded, particularly in the first installment.

Favorite Moments in The Hobbit

Singing the Misty Mountain Song at Bag End

One of my cherished moments in the film adaptation is when the dwarves begin singing the Misty Mountain song at Bag End. This was a forward-looking scene that instilled a sense of hope for the films to come. Although the subsequent films let me down, this scene remains a highlight. It captures exactly what a "Hobbit" film should be – enchanting and magical. The song adds a layer of cultural richness to the story, immersing the audience in a world filled with wonder and adventure.

The "Good Morning" Scene

I also enjoyed several parts that were true to the original book. The "good morning" scene, for example, was a clever exchange in the novel that was flawlessly adapted for the screen. This scene is a testament to the filmmakers' ability to stay faithful to Tolkien's vision while still bringing the story to life in a cinematic manner.

Riddles in the Dark

The Climax: Riddles in the Dark

Among all the scenes, Riddles in the Dark holds a special place in my heart. Both the book and the film adaptations shined here, as the riddles served as a crucial turning point in the narrative. The adaptation was particularly brilliant, as it retained the spirit of the original while enhancing it with cinematic flair. This scene showcases the depth of Bilbo's character and sets the tone for the battles to come. It was a monumental achievement in the trilogy, and it remains a gold standard for the films.

The scene's impact is amplified by the performances and the CGI effects. Smaug, the dragon, is brought to life with a captivating demeanor. Benedict Cumberbatch's portrayal of Smaug combines intimidation, intelligence, and a sense of charm, making him a formidable and memorable adversary. The detailed motion capture CGI ensures that Smaug appears lifelike and menacing, making his interrogation of Bilbo all the more impactful. The Full Reveal of Smaug is, without a doubt, the best scene in the entire trilogy.

Overall Thoughts

In retrospect, I can acknowledge that the films did not get everything right. However, they succeeded in capturing the essence and the most crucial scenes of the original story. Bag End being invaded by dwarves, Gandalf and Bilbo's first meeting, and the Misty Mountain song are superb examples of faithful adaptations. The filmmakers were able to honor Tolkien's work while elevating it to the grandeur of cinema. While there were instances where the films faltered, the highlights remain unforgettable.

It's clear that the Hobbit film trilogy, despite its flaws, managed to resonate with me and countless other fans. In a world inundated with adaptations, it stands as a testament to the power of staying true to source material while embracing the possibilities of filmmaking. Though not everything was perfect, these films continue to hold a special place in my heart for their rich storytelling and memorable moments.