The Golden Companions: Who Was the Best Female Companion in Doctor Who?

Doctor Who has captured the hearts of many fans around the world with its compelling stories and convincing characters. One of the most crucial elements in these stories is the relationship between the Doctor and their companions, marking a significant part of the narrative. However, this article will focus on a specific subset of these characters: the female companions who were human, or came from a different time or place, and who often acted as the Doctor's eyes and ears in unfamiliar settings. Let's venture into the timey-wimey vortex to explore who among them was the best female companion in Doctor Who's long and storied history.

Contemporary Human Female: Sarah Jane Smith and Liz Shaw

The series New Who has brought us a fresh batch of iconic characters who have played a pivotal role in the narrative, and Sarah Jane Smith and Liz Shaw are no exception. Sarah Jane Smith, played by Liz Smith, was the first companion for the New Who incarnation of the Doctor, providing critical backstory and reflecting on the present from a seasoned perspective. Since her initial appearance in 2005, Sarah Jane has left an indelible mark, becoming one of the beloved characters of the show. She is known for her wit, intelligence, and her steadfast loyalty to the Doctor. On the other hand, Liz Shaw, portrayed by Freema Agyeman, was a more contemporary counterpart to Sarah Jane, emerging in the first season of New Who. As a scientific researcher and journalist, Liz brought a different kind of expertise and perspective to the table, making her a formidable ally on board the TARDIS. Her departure from the show marked a significant moment, but her impact on the narrative and the development of the Doctor was profound.

Contemporary Human Male: Ian Chesterton and Graham

While the title of female companion is in question, it is essential to mention the human male companions from contemporary Earth - Ian Chesterton and Graham O'Brien. Ian Chesterton, portrayed by William Russell, was a pivotal figure in the classical era of Doctor Who, accompanying the Second Doctor from 1963 to 1966. Although he was not a primary companion, his relationship with the Doctor was significant and enduring. In the New Who era, Graham O'Brien, played by Bradley Walsh, was introduced and quickly became a vital part of the team, providing comic relief and a modern, relatable perspective to the show. Graham has been a valuable companion, helping to navigate the peculiarities of modern life alongside the Doctor.

Human Female from a Different Time: Romana 1 and Romana 2

From a different time, consider the legacy of Romana, who graced the show in both its classic and revival eras. Romana I, played by Lucy Tovey, was the TARDIS's original female Time Lady codified companion to the Seventh Doctor in the 1980s. With her distinct and charming personality, Romana II, played by Sophie Guru, continued the legacy in the revival era. Both characters brought a sense of playfulness and intelligence to the show, making them beloved companions. Their presence in the narrative provided a unique dynamic, blending the historical context of the original TARDIS expeditions with the modern revival's fresh perspectives.

Non Human or Human Female from a Different Time: Adric and Jamie McCrimmon

The non-human companions, Adric from the TCN-1 era, played by Mark Hindson, and Jamie McCrimmon, a human from the 17th century, played by Frazer Hines, are two significant figures in Doctor Who's extensive history. Adric's scientific knowledge and logical thinking made him a valuable ally, while Jamie's feisty and determined nature often brought levity to the plot. Both characters faced significant challenges and growth throughout their time with the Doctor, leaving lasting impressions.

Honourable Mentions: Amy Pond, WPC Ish, and Ace

Understanding the best female companion is impossible without honouring Amy Pond, played by Kim Pearson, who appeared in the New Who series and was a key player in the Doctor's 11th incarnation. Similarly, WPC Ish and Ace, who have also played crucial roles, are essential to the narrative, each bringing a unique flavor and prowess to the story.

Concluding Thoughts

The debate over the best female companion in Doctor Who is multifaceted, encompassing a wide array of factors, including story arcs, character development, and audience connections. Each companion, whether human or not, plays a unique role in the show's narrative, contributing to the rich tapestry of stories and experiences. For many, Sarah Jane Smith stands out as a beacon of intelligence, courage, and support, but the choice ultimately depends on the viewer's individual experience and affinity for specific storylines and characters.