The Godfather Part II: Michael Corleone's Choices and Strategies in the Assassination of Hyman Roth

In The Godfather Part II, Michael Corleone's decision to send Rocco Lampone to carry out the assassination of Hyman Roth instead of just any hitman reflects several strategic and personal considerations. This choice underscores the blend of personal loyalty, strategic thinking, and the emotional weight of critical decisions he must make as head of the Corleone family.

Trust and Loyalty

Michael's choice of Rocco Lampone, a trusted member of his inner circle, to carry out the hit is not without its strategic implications. By ensuring that his trusted enforcer undertakes the task, Michael minimizes the risk of complications or betrayal. Rocco's loyalty is particularly crucial given the high stakes involved in targeting Roth. Michael needs to send a powerful signal that no one, not even his closest allies, is above suspicion.

Experience and Competence

Rocco has demonstrated his capabilities numerous times, making him a reliable enforcer in Michael's operation. Given the critical nature of the assassination, Michael likely believes that Rocco possesses the necessary skills and decisiveness to execute the task effectively. Roth, being a significant threat to Michael's power and safety, merited the involvement of someone of Rocco's caliber. This decision reflects Michael's understanding that the operation requires precision and courage, traits that Rocco exemplifies.

Personal Stakes

The assassination of Roth is more than just a business decision; it is deeply personal for Michael. Roth represents not only a rival but also someone who has betrayed Michael and attempted to undermine him. Michael's decision to use Rocco, whom he trusts implicitly, may be intended to send a message about the severity of the situation and his resolve to handle it. By involving a close ally, Michael leverages Rocco's emotional investment in the Corleone family and his loyalty to Michael, emphasizing the personal nature of this operation.

Symbolic Gesture and Transformation

The choice of a loyal soldier like Rocco also symbolizes a shift in Michael's leadership style. The film highlights his transformation from a more detached, business-like approach to a more personal and emotional involvement in his family's affairs. This change in leadership style is a reflection of Michael's maturation and the evolving dynamics within the Corleone family.

Theoretical Speculation: Misstep or Betrayal?

My head canon answer, while not substantiated by the movie itself, offers an alternative perspective on Michael's decision. It is possible that Rocco's family was ensured special treatment, prompting him to volunteer for the mission. Alternatively, Rocco may have betrayed Michael by opening the curtains and allowing the shooters a better shot, only to silence the gunmen afterward to avoid implicating himself.

In this scenario, Michael might have discovered the truth of Rocco's involvement, allowing him to serve two purposes with this single decision: eliminating both Hyman Roth and Rocco Lampone. This perspective adds depth to the characters and underscores the complex, often tragic nature of the Corleone family's operations.

While these theories are not backed by any explicit evidence from the film, they provide a compelling narrative that enriches the viewer's understanding of the characters and the delicate balance of trust, loyalty, and strategic thinking exhibited by Michael Corleone.

Conclusion

Making these decisions is a testament to Michael Corleone's skill and character. The intertwining of personal and professional considerations in his leadership style is a hallmark of the Godfather saga, making this film a masterclass in dramatic storytelling and family dynamics.