The Feasibility and Implications of Russia Becoming the USSR Again

It is highly improbable that Russia would return to become the USSR again. A variety of socio-political, economic, and cultural factors contribute to this conclusion. This article explores the challenges and implications of such a scenario, based on the current state of Russia.

The Downward Spiral of Russia

The ongoing conflict with Ukraine has significantly worsened Russia's global standing and internal stability. Russia is currently on a downward spiral, marked by geopolitical isolation and an internal economic decline. These factors make it difficult for Russia to revert to the former USSR structure.

Failure of the USSR Model in Modern Russia

Compared to the USSR, Russia's current political and economic model is vastly different. The USSR's structure hinged on centralized power, rigid control, and a command economy. Modern Russia, under President Putin's leadership, has implemented a more flexible and market-oriented economic model, albeit with heavy state control. The idea that 'we are feeding the whole Union' is seen as outdated and unattractive by Russians today. This conception was popular during the Soviet era but does not resonate in today's context.

Cultural and Ideological Landscape

Russians have largely moved away from Western cultural ideas and lifestyle norms. While certain aspects of American life, such as the homeless issue and urban ghettos, are discussed, there is a rejection of the liberal values that emerged in the West. The Soviet system, with its own set of flaws, is seen as superior by many Russians, both in terms of stability and efficiency. The period in the 1990s, characterized by economic collapse and political instability, is still fresh in the collective memory. This period served as a stark contrast to the current system under Putin, which is viewed as more stable.

The Crisis of Liberal Ideologies

Liberal ideas and forces in Russia are at a critical juncture. These ideologies have lost much of their popular support within Russia. While foreign supporters continue to prop up these ideas, their struggle is akin to a losing bet on a very old horse. These ideologies are no longer viable in Russia’s current political climate. The Western liberal forces are heavily criticized and lack the support necessary to gain traction.

Ethnic and Political Diversity in Russia

Despite the opposition to liberal ideologies, Russia is a diverse nation with a range of political viewpoints. Some Russians advocate for socialist or communist systems, while others support a restoration of the Russian Empire or partial restoration of its past greatness. Moderate and extremist views exist within these factions, but the majority are not in conflict. In instances like the 2014-2022 Donbass war, both sides have shown a willingness to collaborate for shared goals, suggesting a potential for unity under certain circumstances. However, the majority of Russians are against disruptive forces seeking to dismantle the current political order.

Internal Stability and Recent Protests

The recent failed attempt by Arkady Prigozhin to manipulate public opinion and trigger unrest is a telling example of the current political dynamics. Prigozhin’s initial popularity dropped precipitously, indicating a low tolerance for disruptive political actions. This event highlights the difficulty of countering established political structures from within and the stronger adherence to the current political model.

In conclusion, the return of Russia to the USSR model is highly improbable due to a combination of historical context, economic and political realities, and the current cultural landscape. The current political structure, while facing its own challenges, remains resilient and favored by the majority of the Russian population.